Thursday, November 18, 2010

Lawyer/Guardian Cleared in Negligence Case

An attorney who was accused of negligence in the guardianship of an 83-year-old woman by the woman's family has been cleared of all allegations by a jury.

A daughter of Nannie McIntosh, Isabella Bennington had filed the civil suit against Tresa Gossett, a Bethel, Ohio attorney who serves as solicitor for the village of Aberdeen, Ohio. The civil case was unrelated to any duties Gossett has with the village.

Bennington alleged in her civil case that Gossett was not only negligent, but had converted some of her mother's property. She filed the suit in August, 2009.

Gossett filed a counter-complaint that the family was abusing a judicial process.

The case went to trial Monday, with Bennington's attorney, James Banks, outlining several specific accusations in his opening statement. Among those accusations, that Gossett did not permit McIntosh's daughters to visit her in the nursing homes where she spent the last several months of her life, that she failed to set up a payment arrangement for McIntosh's supplemental insurance, resulting in its cancellation and that items went missing from the home for which Gossett, as guardian, would have been responsible.

Gossett's attorney, Rick Weil, countered those claims in his opening statements mostly through the use of a time line beginning with a police report of a theft of $36,000 in January, 2007, long before Gossett knew the family. He also played a 911 recording in which one sister accused another of abusing their mother and described other calls placed by McIntosh in which she said she needed assistance with her medication and asked the dispatchers if they would like to buy a quilt.

Those 911 calls prompted protective services to become involved. Weil said probate court recommended an attorney as guardian because the family couldn't agree on a guardian.

Weil said Gossett had more than two decades experience as an attorney and no prior complaints of anything unethical. He described her as the "go-to" person for the court when there is need of a guardian.

Full Article and Source:
Lawyer Cleared in Negligence Case

See Also:
OH: Family Files Suit Against Guardian

7 comments:

Connie said...

I can't believe it!

Steve said...

I am so sorry for this family. Unfortunately, I bet the jury doesn't even know about guardianship abuse.

Ted said...

Come on, a jury sanctioned this behavior? That hurts. One would think a jury wouldn't allow it.

Anonymous said...

Very sad and surprising.

I hope the Nannie McIntosh family finds and joins NASGA.

Barbara said...

This is indeed a major set bck.

I am sorry, Isabella. I believe you stood up for your Mom and did your very best. And I am sorry a jury let you/her down.

Mike said...

I wish we could hear from the jury. I wonder what would have convinced them.

Jes said...

It appears Nannie McIntosh was isolated from her own daughers.

And the jury thought this was ok?

Help us all.