It reads like an outline for a B-grade detective novel: A reclusive elderly couple with no close relatives lives in a house crammed with jewelry, stamp collections, stock certificates and dozens of pieces of art worth, conservatively, $3 million. Throw in a huge model train collection, too. And rats. Don't forget the rats.Because it's the discovery of the rats by city health inspectors that eventually forces the couple to go live in a hotel, leaving their fortunes behind in their Berkeley home, intermingled with mounds of trash. But they assume they are taken care of -- their neighbor is a lawyer, soon to become an Alameda County Superior Court judge. The couple places him in charge of their belongings and money, trusting him to manage their estate while they are away.
It is not, however, a novel. According to new details revealed this week in an 87-page affidavit written by a veteran District Attorney inspector, it is how Superior Court Judge Paul Seeman, 57, came to be arrested June 14 and charged with elder theft and perjury. He is free on $525,000 bail after pleading not guilty. The case is scheduled for a court hearing next month; Seeman won a motion at his arraignment to not attend minor legal proceedings
He "does not intend to return to the bench until this matter is resolved," his lawyer, Laurel Headley, said in a prepared statement issued Thursday. Headley declined to take questions, but the statement said the judge is looking forward to "all the facts in this case coming to light in a fair and complete" trial.
Seeman could also be impeached by the state Assembly, and the State Commission on Judicial Power is mulling suspending him as the criminal charges unfold. If convicted, Seeman, who then-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger appointed to the bench in 2009, would immediately be forced from office.
Seeman told police that he was just trying to help the couple, Lee and Anne Nutting. Lee Nutting, a chemist who worked for Hills Brother's Coffee, died in 1999. Anne Nutting, who headed the Berkeley Public Library's Art and Music Department, was still struggling with Seeman to regain control of her assets when she died in 2010 at 97, the affidavit states.
Full Article and Source:
Alameda County judge charged in elder abuse case to take leave of absence; affidavit outlines charges
See Also:
CA: Alameda County Judge Charged With Elder Theft
He needs to be off the bench while the charges are being pursued for sure. Leave of absense? Maybe that's fair at this point.
ReplyDeleteWill any NASGA members join others like myself in advocating a constitutional amendment which will guaranttee everyone the rights they need to present to a jury, without hindrance, their evidence of a legal professional's negligence or dishonesty? I might soon need to curtail my own efforts in this and related regards as a result of an unacceptable price increase by my ISP. With this in mind, I am wondering if any NASGA member who has space on a Web server would be willing to post on their space the evidence and information about legal reforms which I have shared with NASGA and others. If so, please let me know within the next couple of days via tvfields@oh.rr.com
ReplyDeleteOff with his gavel!
ReplyDeleteIt would be nice tvfields, if you could meet up with persons wishing to pursue this effort and start a good website like NASGA's and you could share the posting responsibility. You're right that the legal profession needs to be scrutinized, but shouldn't that be done by the individual state judicial discipline committees?
ReplyDeleteWoooohoooo, I'm glad this judge was caught!
ReplyDelete