YPSILANTI TWP., MI — An elected official in Ypsilanti Township and his wife have settled a lawsuit brought by a family member who alleged they took financial advantage of her elderly father who suffered from dementia before his death.
Ypsilanti Township Treasurer Stan Eldridge, his wife Brenda and son Chad were sued by Rhonda McGivney, her sister, in Washtenaw County Probate Court in September 2024. Chad Eldridge was later removed from the suit.
The case was dismissed with prejudice due to the settlement on Nov. 12, according to Washtenaw County court records. That means McGivney cannot file the same complaint again in Washtenaw County or a different court.
McGivney and the Eldridges had entered a settlement agreement on Oct. 2, with county Probate Court Judge Darlene O’Brien approving it Oct. 27.
Details of the settlement were negotiated and reviewed by the judge in closed chambers out of public view.
Attorneys representing McGivney and the Eldridges each declined to comment on the terms of the settlement.
“The settlement is confidential, and I am not able to comment. The parties have had a dispute and it has been resolved,” Jane Bassett, McGivney’s attorney said in a statement to The Ann Arbor News/MLive.
Attorney Matt Jane, who represented the Eldridges, also said the dispute has been resolved.
“I can say nothing, other than the case is settled,” Jane said.
In her complaint, McGivney claimed the Eldridges “engaged in financial abuse and exploitation of a vulnerable adult and a conspiracy to defraud Clarence Erwin of cash and negotiable instruments.”
She claimed it amounted to more than $150,000.
The Eldridges denied all allegations in the lawsuit.
They argued in court filings financial actions taken by Brenda Eldridge were at the direction of her father or “performed of his own accord.”
According to her legal complaint, McGivney was appointed in 2018 as conservator for her and Brenda Eldridge’s father Clarence Erwin, meaning she manages his personal and financial affairs. For years before 2018, Brenda Eldridge assisted their father with financial affairs and real estate.
McGivney’s original complaint also alleged the Eldridges also prepared a deed to Erwin’s home, valued at around $250,000, that named Chad Eldridge a joint tenant with full rights of survivorship, meaning he would automatically inherit the home.
However, Judge O’Brien determined the statute of limitations had run out on the real estate portion of the suit.
McGivney alleged Brenda Eldridge attempted to conceal her father’s condition and submitted “fraudulent and forged correspondence” to a life insurance company and other financial institutions.
The suit alleged Brenda Eldridge transferred $56,000 out of her father’s bank account between April 2016 and August 2018. It also alleged she wrote herself checks in excess of $16,000 and that she forged his signature after arranging to become a joint owner of his bank account, despite not having power of attorney.
More than $43,000 worth of U.S. Treasury Bonds were converted, according to the suit.
It also alleged Brenda Eldridge was involved in getting a document notarized without the notary witnessing Erwin sign it.
The Eldridges have argued “there was no fraud,” according to a court filing.
They have also argued that medical records do not show that Erwin was suffering from dementia at the time of the alleged wrongdoings and that there is no evidence mental derangement had prevented Erwin from understanding his rights.
“Simply put, there is no evidence that Mr. Erwin suffered from anything other than age-related memory issues prior to 2018, which is the subject of this litigation,” the Eldridges argued.
They also argued that the fact that McGivney “felt confident enough in Mr. Erwin’s capacity to have him execute a Durable Power of Attorney in October 2018 speaks for itself.”
Full Article & Source:
Settlement reached in elder financial abuse lawsuit targeting Ypsilanti Township treasurer, wife

No comments:
Post a Comment