Showing posts with label anti-psychotic medications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anti-psychotic medications. Show all posts

Friday, June 7, 2019

Michigan nursing home sued for imprisoning and ransoming woman

By Gretchen Rachel Hammond 

Mimi Brun and her mother, Virginia Wahab

A number of studies have found that the greatest fear expressed by senior citizens, a demographic that’s exponentially growing in number in this country, is not death but the eradication of their independence if they are forced to live in a nursing facility. According to a lawsuit filed on May 8, that fear became reality for a vital and healthy Detroit-area woman, Virginia “Jean” Wahab, who spent two years falsely imprisoned in a Waterford, Michigan, nursing home owned by Lourdes, Inc., and sponsored by the Dominican Sisters of Peace religious order. The home demanded payment of what amounted to a ransom of $25,000 to release Wahab from the facility.

“Mom was a fearless, independent woman before Lourdes took control of her,” Wahab’s daughter and caregiver Mimi Brun said. “When I finally got her out of there, it took me a long time to wean her off all the unnecessary anti-psychotic and anti-depressive drugs they had been giving her.”

Brun is the plaintiff in the lawsuit, which claims her mother was subject to false imprisonment, negligence, breach of contract, malicious prosecution, abuse of court process, and the intentional infliction of emotional distress. Filed in the Oakland County Circuit Court, the complaint is a first for Michigan and comes on the heels of Attorney General Dana Nessel’s creation of an Elder Abuse Task Force.

Brun said that although her mother had been living alone before her ordeal began in 2016, by the time she was able to secure Wahab’s release after a protracted legal battle, “She couldn’t stand up. She was terrified of being locked in a room and of someone coming to take her back to Lourdes.”

Before Wahab passed away at the end of April, mother and daughter were finally able to spend a precious few months together after having been kept apart by a court order obtained by Lourdes that severed Brun’s visitation rights.

Short-term rehab to long-term guardianship


According to the complaint, the family’s problems began in February 2016, when Wahab was admitted to Lourdes Senior Community, a $21 million nonprofit organization housing 250 residents at four facilities, for short-term rehabilitation following a recommendation from her doctor. By April 2016, Wahab’s insurance company, Health Alliance Plan, had terminated Wahab’s Medicare benefits at Lourdes, stating that she needed no further services or medication and was “medically stable for discharge.”

However, the complaint asserts, “Even though Virginia did not need to be in a nursing home, Lourdes kept her in a section reserved for terminally ill and dementia patients for over two years [and] would not release Virginia without the payment of a bill in the amount of $25,000.”

Court documents show that Lourdes filed a June 6, 2016, petition for guardianship of Wahab with the Oakland County Probate Court. During a June 29, 2016, hearing on the petition, Lourdes social worker Sara Van Acker stated that the organization was seeking guardianship of Wahab because of “a concern about the nursing home being paid.”

Without any medical documents regarding Wahab’s alleged incapacity presented at the hearing, presiding Oakland County Probate Court Judge Linda S. Hallmark granted the request and appointed former Oakland County Public Administrator Jon B. Munger as Wahab’s guardian.

Guardianship under scrutiny


Guardianship is a system that has come under scrutiny. Under guardianship, an individual deemed legally incompetent by a probate or family court judge must cede their personal rights, freedoms, financial powers, and medical decisions, often to a total stranger. Cases in which court-appointed professional guardians have used their power to exploit and abuse their elderly or vulnerable wards have been uncovered nationwide. A 2015 Hunter College/New York Times study determined that the use of guardianship as a collection agency by nursing facilities has “become routine.”

Despite a statute in Michigan’s Estates and Protected Individuals Code (EPIC) giving Brun priority over a professional guardian in the care of her mother, Judge Hallmark stated that she was appointing Munger “to make sure we have the Medicaid application on track [and] get this bill taken care of.”
According to Brun’s lawsuit, Wahab was “kept in Lourdes against her will in exchange for the Medicaid payments [and] as collateral for payments it claimed were owed to it by Ms. Brun.”

The fight to be reunited


During the two-year fight Brun waged to have Wahab released from both the guardianship and the nursing home, the complaint alleges, Lourdes denied Brun visitation rights and barred her from the premises; chemically restrained Wahab while denying her personal liberty and freedom of movement; and obtained an illegal injunction from Hallmark and a bench warrant for Brun’s arrest unless she paid them $25,000.

The complaint notes a Feb. 2, 2017, email from Lourdes attorney Mary Lyneis telling Brun, “We want to be paid. You cannot expect to show up to see your mother when you have not paid for the privilege.”

A disturbing June 27, 2018, video shows a brief reunion between mother and daughter outside the Oakland County Probate Court before Munger’s attorney Joseph Ehrlich pulls Wahab’s wheelchair away with such force that Wahab is jolted back in her seat. Brun said her reaction was visceral and born out of exhaustion, frustration, and helplessness. “I hadn’t seen my mother for two years,” she recalled. “They had no right to separate us. What Ehrlich did was aggressive and illegal. If it was your mom, what would you do?”

Ultimately, Brun decided the answer was to take legal action against Lourdes and to seek justice—but not only for Wahab. “The irreparable suffering in my mom’s case, the inhumanity she was subjected to, the illegalities and the breaches of her legal and human rights cannot be repeated to anyone else anywhere,” she said.

Respecting rights


Passed in 1987, the federal Nursing Home Reform Act is supposed to require facilities to ensure the rights and protection of residents. Representing Brun in the case, Michigan trial attorney Mark Hafeli noted that the nursing home’s alleged actions were in violation of those rights. “All federal regulations and resident rights say that a resident of a nursing home has a right to visits. You can’t condition a mother’s right to see her daughter based upon the daughter’s payment of $25,000. To be locked in a nursing home when you don’t want to be there is a serious wrong,” Hafeli said.

Even though the act stipulates that in cases where a resident has been deemed incompetent by a state judge, their rights are transferred to a guardian, Hafeli does not believe it lets Lourdes off the hook for filing an unwarranted petition in the first place and holding, isolating, and treating Wahab in a negligent manner. “According to an expert I have consulted, regardless of what the guardian may or may not do, the nursing home has a duty to discharge a person when they don’t need skilled nursing care,” he said, “especially when there’s a family member willing to take care of them.”

Diane Menio is the executive director of the Center for Advocacy for the Rights and Interests of the Elderly, which promotes “the wellbeing, rights and autonomy of older adults.”  Menio said, “There are national trends such as nursing homes going for a guardianship when they can’t get payment or an application for Medicaid. But you can’t keep someone hostage until money is paid. A family member being told ‘you can’t visit because you owe us money’ is something new to me.”

Menio noted that her organization has lately seen nursing facilities applying for guardianship of their residents “in batches.” Such activity raises the question of whether a reason for the increase in guardianship and nursing home abuse is an increasing senior demographic that, both politically and culturally, the United States would prefer to ignore. “Society doesn’t see elderly people,” Menio agreed. “The abuse of them is underreported. People take advantage of them. Making sure we have protections in place for the elderly population is extremely challenging.”

Brun said that her lawsuit is part of a greater elder-abuse awareness campaign she calls #justiceforjean. “People need to wake up about the potential for destructive forces in the lives of people they love,” she said.

Reached by email, Debi Batchelder, assistant to Lourdes Senior Community CEO Sister Maureen Comer, said the organization had no comment on the lawsuit or the allegations.

Gretchen Rachel Hammond is an award-winning journalist whose body of investigative work has focused on social injustice and marginalized communities. She has just completed a year-long investigation into a massive, alleged elder abuse and exploitation ring operating out of a Detroit-area probate court, which will be published soon.

Full Article & Source:
Michigan nursing home sued for imprisoning and ransoming woman

Monday, June 25, 2018

This Kansas nursing home had high rates of mind-altering meds. Today, that has changed

Dorothy "Dottie" Morgan gets assistance from her daughter, Deanna Seimsen, middle, and her husband, Ted Morgan, inside the Kearny County Hospital's assisted living facility in Lakin

Read more here: http://www.kansas.com/news/state/article212842959.html#storylink=cpy

  When Dorothy “Dottie” Morgan entered High Plains Retirement Village in Lakin, she was already on at least one anti-psychotic medication. 

Risperdal — and the other anti-psychotic medications she received on an as needed basis — has a “black box” warning for elders, the strictest warning from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

In 2016, 20 percent of all Kansas long-term nursing home residents had an anti-psychotic medication at some point in the year. That tied Kansas for the highest rate with Oklahoma and Mississippi.

Those medications, which are intended for serious mental health issues such as psychosis and schizophrenia, can increase the risk of falls, heart attacks, strokes and more, particularly for the elderly. They are not recommended for someone with dementia, like Morgan.

Today, those rates have declined across the country, throughout Kansas and at High Plains Retirement Village, which is located at Kearny County Hospital.

‘Zombie like’


As Morgan’s dementia worsened, it was hard for family to know whether the medicine or her disease was changing her. She was lethargic, “kind of zombie like,” uninterested in anything, said Ted Morgan, her husband. She had difficulty moving and hardly seemed to notice when people walked by. 

For years, prescribing anti-psychotics for nursing home residents who were difficult to control was common practice, said Mary Chipley, director of nursing at the hospital. When physical restraints ceased to be used in the late 80s and early 90s, nursing homes moved to chemical restraints.

Chipley first learned that the hospital had high rates of anti-psychotic usage shortly after becoming the new director of nursing. In a short period of time, she received a state survey, heard from the Kansas Partnership to Improve Dementia Care and was surveyed by federal regulators.

With 38 percent of residents on anti-psychotics, Kearny County had the second highest rate in Kansas — a state that, at the time, had the highest rates in the nation. (Nursing home advocates point out that Kansas has nine designated Nursing Facilities for Mental Health, which are unique to Kansas and make up nine of the top 10 homes in the state for anti-psychotic use. That has raised Kansas’ ranking). 

In just 18 months, rates at Kearny County Hospital have dropped from 38.2 percent to 8 percent. The one resident remaining on anti-psychotic medications has a psychiatric diagnosis for which the medications are approved. 

With the physicians on board, they began to gradually reduce the medications. Chipley required nurses to receive approval from her before asking a physician for anti-psychotic medications for a resident. Consultants came in to offer training on how to handle difficult behaviors without medication.

One of the most important elements was completing a “life story” for each resident. In it, staff met with family members to find out about the resident’s personality, history, comfort foods and more. 

That allows staff to better manage behaviors if they know the root cause. Perhaps a favorite comfort food can be used to help someone calm down. When a resident tries to get out of the locked area, staff might take him for a walk rather than making him immediately return indoors. 

Siemsen, the Morgans’ daughter, said one of the greatest successes was explaining to the staff that her mother didn’t like being ordered around. 

“If you ask her, ‘Hey Miss Dottie, would you like to go have an ice cream?’ if you ask Miss Dottie and approach it that way, she’s much, much more receptive than if you just tell her it’s time for lunch,” Siemsen said.

It can be hard to understand the needs and desires of someone with dementia, Chipley said. Knowing their histories helps people to understand how they think and behave.

“A please and a thank you go a long way with her (Miss Dottie),” Chipley said. “That’s still there. She still wants you to use your manners.”

Another resident was a homemaker. In the past, if she had become upset after lunch, staff might not have known why and opted for anti-psychotic medication. Now, they know she wants to wash dishes every day, so they let her.

Changing mindset


No nursing home wants to put their residents on these medications, said Benjamin Anderson, CEO of the hospital, but they sometimes don’t have the tools to do otherwise. 

“The difference (here) has been a nurse leader who was willing to say there’s another way,” Anderson said. 

It takes a while for people to change the mindset of “that’s just the way they’ve always done it,” said Tim Keck, secretary of the Kansas Department for Aging and Disability Services. 

“It really starts with focusing on the person, person-centered care, and thinking about what would you want for yourself or your family member,” Keck said. “You start there.” 

Debra Zehr, CEO of LeadingAge Kansas, the statewide association of nonprofit long term and aging care providers, also referenced creating “a person centered place for people to call home” when she recognized Kearny County Hospital for the decrease in medications last week.

What’s being done at the hospital is also happening around the state as people become better educated, Zehr said.

Data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services shows that anti-psychotic use for long-term nursing home residents has declined in Kansas from about 26 percent when the rate was first measured in 2011 to 18.4 percent in the fourth quarter of 2017, moving Kansas to 45th in the country.

Ted Morgan said he’s seen a world of difference in his wife since she stopped taking the anti-psychotic medications.

On Tuesday, “Miss Dottie” was alert, curious about a Wichita Eagle photographer’s camera and eager to show off her pastel pink fingernails.

She might not know who residents, staff and visitors are, said Ted Morgan, but she pays attention to them once again. Before the medications, she loved the outdoors, flowers, grass, books, reading, family photos, pictures and paintings. Those interests have returned, her family say. 

“If she can be off the antipsychotic medication and function fine in her environment and have a little more response to her environment, then absolutely, why wouldn’t you do that?” Ted Morgan asked.

Chipley says others have had similar reactions to being taken off their medications. At first there was some resistance among staff, but they came on board when they noticed the change.

“It was like they were coming alive again,” Chipley said. “It wasn’t just people sitting in recliners anymore sleeping. It was going outside. It was doing an activity. It was being up and moving around, having a conversation. It was almost becoming a person again.”
d more here: http://www.kansas.com/news/state/article212842959.html#storylink=cpy


Full Article & Source:
This Kansas nursing home had high rates of mind-altering meds. Today, that has changed

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

The Agonizing Limbo Of Abandoned Nursing Home Residents


Bruce Anderson about a year before his accident.
A bad bout of pneumonia sent Bruce Anderson to Sutter Medical Center in Sacramento last May. As soon as he recovered, hospital staff tried to return him to the nursing home where he had been living for four years.

But the home refused to readmit him, even after being ordered to do so by the state. Nearly nine months later, Anderson, 66, is still in the hospital.

“I’m frustrated,” said his daughter, Sara Anderson. “You cannot just dump someone in the hospital.”

Anderson said her father, who has a brain injury that causes dementia-like symptoms, is confined to the hospital bed and frequently given anti-psychotic medications. She believes the nursing home, Norwood Pines Alzheimer’s Care Center, refused to readmit him because it wanted to make room for more lucrative and less burdensome residents.

“I didn’t have any question this was about money,” she said.

Bruce Anderson is the victim of a flawed readmission system for patients who want to return to their nursing homes after spending time in the hospital.

Nursing home residents are entitled to hearings under federal law to determine whether they should be readmitted after hospitalization. The state Department of Health Care Services holds the administrative hearings, but has said it is not responsible for enforcing the rulings.

But the state Department of Public Health, which oversees nursing homes, neglects to enforce the rulings and sometimes disagrees with them, according to advocates and court documents.

That leaves residents like Anderson, who won his hearing in July, with little recourse — and not many places to go. And since many nursing home residents have publicly-funded insurance, it means taxpayers are on the hook for hospital stays long after the patients are ready for discharge.

“Federal and state law have created a complicated and expensive process to ensure residents are not abandoned by their nursing homes,” said Tony Chicotel, a staff attorney at the nonprofit California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform. “It fundamentally doesn’t work.”  (Continue)

Full Article & Source:
The Agonizing Limbo Of Abandoned Nursing Home Residents