Judge questions former Sullivan County public guardian about multiple guardianship cases

Former Sullivan County public administrator Joan Brummitt answered for her oversight as guardian

by Matt Flener

MILAN, Mo. —  A former Sullivan County elected public official faced pointed questions from a judge on Tuesday for how she handled the estates of 13 people whom she oversaw as guardian or conservator.

The judge ordered former longtime Sullivan County Public Administrator Joan Brummitt to appear before him on Tuesday — in one case asking why she did not transfer more than $400,000 from a ward’s estate to the new public administrator in the county after Brummitt resigned from office.

Sullivan County Associate Circuit Judge Adam Warren on Tuesday, after hearing an explanation from Brummitt’s attorney, gave Brummitt more time to transfer ownership of that specific ward’s bank and brokerage accounts to the new county public administrator before holding her in contempt.

In 12 other probate cases of former wards, Warren cited Brummitt for failing to file various reports. Brummitt cleared most of those cases by filing the reports in the court record and before Warren on Tuesday.

Brummitt declined to comment to KMBC 9 News about the cases.

Brummitt’s court appearance marks the latest questions from a judge.

In a separate criminal case, she is facing four felony counts of financial exploitation of an older/disabled person and four felony counts of stealing $750 or more.

She has pleaded not guilty.

Brummitt, in her role as Sullivan County Public Administrator, had the responsibility to care for wards of the state.

Public administrators are elected in Missouri to take care of financial and medical decisions for elderly or mentally ill patients when a judge decides family or friends can no longer care for them.

Court documents in Brummitt's criminal case

Previous court documents allege Brummitt moved money last October from an elderly ward’s bank account to her personal bank account on four separate occasions.

A Missouri State Highway Patrol investigator said on Oct. 14, 2025, Brummitt used her personal cell phone and online banking app to send money from the ward’s account through three separate transactions, totaling $999, $1,900 and $1,980.

She made another online $999 transfer on Oct. 16, the MSHP investigator said in court documents.

The total amount came to $5,878.

Brummitt is charged with four felony counts of financial exploitation of an older/disabled person and four felony counts of stealing $750 or more.

A Missouri State Highway Patrol investigator testified last month that Brummitt admitted to the highway patrol that she moved money from the ward’s account to hers.

The investigator told the court that Brummitt admitted to highway patrol investigators that hackers told her to move the money.

Brummitt’s criminal attorney, Mark Williams, has previously told KMBC 9 News that Brummitt is innocent until proven guilty.

In a series called "Paper Prisons," KMBC 9 News is investigating ways to systemically improve the care of those under guardianship by highlighting stories of people struggling to navigate a tangled system of legal paperwork, medical records and court orders.

If you have a tip about a Missouri guardianship case, email investigates@kmbc.com. 

Full Article & Source:
Judge questions former Sullivan County public guardian about multiple guardianship cases 

See Also:
Sullivan County elected official accused of stealing thousands from disabled person

Missouri elected guardian charged with 8 felonies for stealing from ward

Missouri public guardian pleads not guilty to eight felony counts

Judge: Missouri public guardian’s felony financial crime case can move forward   

You May Also Be Interested In: 

Paper Prisons: Missouri woman details struggle to leave public guardianship after husband's death

Paper Prisons: Missouri man continues fight to free his mother from public guardianship 

Judge: Missouri public guardian’s felony financial crime case can move forward

Sullivan County Public Administrator Joan Brummitt is charged with eight felonies connected to alleged financial crimes

by Matt Flener

MILAN, Mo. — A Missouri elected public guardian’s felony financial crime case will move forward after a preliminary hearing at the Sullivan County courthouse on Wednesday.

Joan Brummitt is accused of stealing nearly $6,000 from a ward of the state under her care, according to court documents.

Brummitt, in her role as Sullivan County Public Administrator, has the responsibility to care for wards of the state.

Public administrators are elected in Missouri to take care of financial and medical decisions for elderly or mentally ill patients when a judge decides family or friends can no longer care for them.

Brummitt appeared in court with her attorney, Mark Williams.

Williams cross-examined Missouri State Highway Patrol investigator Barbara Littrell about Brummitt’s admission to the highway patrol that she moved money from the ward’s account to hers.

Littrell told the court that Brummitt admitted to highway patrol investigators that hackers told her to move the money.

“Bottom line is she conducted the transfers,” Littrell said on the witness stand before Ninth Circuit Court Presiding Judge Terry Tschannen.

Littrell told the court that she worked with employees at Putnam County State Bank to uncover the alleged crimes.

KMBC asked Brummitt’s attorney if she was coerced or told to transfer the ward’s money into her personal account.

“Either that or if they were hacking into her phone,” said Mark Williams. “Regardless of what she thought, you know, they could do it anyway, because as I cross-examined the officer, there are ways depending on the bank and the security system the bank has that they can access people's accounts and they can go back and forth on your own account if you have more than one account.”

Judge Tschannen found enough probable cause existed to keep the case moving forward to trial. He referred the case to allow the Missouri Supreme Court to choose another judge.

Court documents allege Brummitt moved money in October from an elderly ward’s bank account to her personal bank account on four separate occasions.

A Missouri State Highway Patrol investigator said on Oct. 14, 2025, Brummitt used her personal cell phone and online banking app to send money from the ward’s account through three separate transactions, totaling $999, $1,900 and $1,980.

She made another online $999 transfer on Oct. 16, the MSHP investigator said in court documents.

The total amount came to $5,878.

Brummitt is charged with four felony counts of financial exploitation of an older/disabled person and four felony counts of stealing $750 or more.

Brummitt still holds office. But a judge has restricted her from making financial decisions on behalf of her wards.

In a series called "Paper Prisons," KMBC 9 News is investigating ways to systemically improve the care of those under guardianship by highlighting stories of people struggling to navigate a tangled system of legal paperwork, medical records and court orders. 

Full Article & Source:
Judge: Missouri public guardian’s felony financial crime case can move forward

See Also:
Missouri public guardian pleads not guilty to eight felony counts

Missouri elected guardian charged with 8 felonies for stealing from ward