Showing posts with label guardianship reform bills. Show all posts
Showing posts with label guardianship reform bills. Show all posts

Thursday, August 1, 2024

Families testify during State Senate committee hearing on guardianship reform bills


By: Heather Catallo , Brandon Speagle

(WXYZ) — Give us our families back and change the laws. That was the constant refrain from families Tuesday during testimony in front of a state senate committee hearing on guardianship reform.

The 7 Investigators have been exposing problems in the state’s guardianship system since 2017, and now there are several proposed guardianship law reforms still under consideration in Lansing.

On Tuesday, families had the chance to tell state senators how much guardianships have hurt them, and why they want the laws to change.

VIDEO: Sparks fly in Lansing as probate judges push back on proposed guardianship reforms


“How would you like it if it was one of your family members that was handcuffed, detained, or even arrested for standing up against this abuse,”
said Jodi White about the state’s probate court system.


The Michigan Senate Civil Rights, Judiciary and Public Safety Committee listened to three hours of public testimony from local families who are desperate to reform the state’s guardianship and conservatorship laws.

“I want to thank Channel 7 and Heather Catallo who has done stories about abuse in the system, and that’s what we have to do is make sure people know-- because it hasn’t changed,” said Senator Ruth Johnson (R-Holly), who has been trying to get reform legislation passed for several years.


Attorney General Dana Nessel’s Elder Abuse Task Force has worked for five years to create legislation to increase protections for vulnerable adults.

VIDEO: Community steps in to help special needs man save childhood home in guardianship battle


If you’re declared legally incapacitated and put under guardianship, you lose the right to make your own medical and financial decisions.

Families have alleged for years that judges appoint professional guardians who then separate loved ones from their families and drain their estates.

VIDEO: Michigan woman makes history in guardianship case, advocates for alternative option


“I would go on to have 7 attorneys and over $200,000 in legal fees fighting for my mother. My mother would be isolated for 14 months,”
said Cynthia Mifsud.


The bills would provide several protections, including making sure probate judges put their reasons on the court record if they choose a professional guardian over a family member, and they would require more detailed reports from those appointed to evaluate whether someone needs a guardian.

 Still opposing the bills are the Michigan Guardianship Association and several probate judges.

“Stop favoring the state bar and their attorneys so people can protect the wards and their loved ones,” said Jeff White.


 “I expected the judge to follow the rules and her cannons. She did everything except that. She had her own agenda and her own guardian to assign to my mom,” said Christine Abood.


Committee Chair Senator Stephanie Chang thanked everyone who testified today and said they are taking this issue very seriously.

Senator Chang said she hopes to finish the work on the bills in committee and to vote in the fall.

VIDEO: Detroit man who is Deaf-Blind freed after spending more than 2 years under guardianship

Full Article & Source:
Families testify during State Senate committee hearing on guardianship reform bills

Saturday, September 30, 2023

Guardianship reform bills would put Office of State Guardian into place in Michigan

By: Heather Catallo

(WXYZ) — The 7 Investigators have been exposing problems in Michigan’s guardianship system for six years. Today new plans were announced to bring additional oversight to the probate court system that many advocates say can hurt families and cost people their life savings.

We first told you about the idea for the Office of State Guardian back in April. Now that bill has been officially introduced and more details are emerging about the oversight it will potentially bring to a system many families complain about.

Currently in Michigan, if you’re having problems with a court-appointed guardian there’s no agency with oversight where you can file a complaint. If the new law passes, that could change.

Since 2017, the 7 Investigators have been exposing abuses in Michigan’s guardianship system. In one brief court hearing, with very little evidence, you can be declared legally incapacitated, and all your rights can vanish.

In response to our years of reporting, several bills have been introduced in Lansing to bring reforms.

“This is a bi-partisan package. It is a clear example of how government can be an instrument of good,” said House Judiciary Committee Chair Rep. Kelly Breen (D-Novi) during testimony Wednesday.

“The more common sense guardrails that we put around the system, the more vulnerable or elderly folks we protect,” said Rep. Graham Filler (R-St. Johns) while testifying in front of the committee Wednesday.

If passed, the package of five bills will do everything from requiring guardians to visit their wards more often, to making sure you have the right to an attorney if you’re being put under guardianship.

The newest change is a bill that would establish the Office of State Guardian.

“This Office of State Guardian would be responsible for receiving complaints and investigating them against guardians and conservators who are believed to be enacting financial or other abuses on their wards. The goal is that the OSG would then work with the Attorney General’s office on complaints that did involve improper criminal conduct,” said Rep. Betsy Coffia (D-Traverse City).

Other changes proposed: certification and a way to compensate professional guardians for their work – but also consequences if they break the rules.

“It’s basic stuff, that says ‘okay we’re going to make sure you’re not a criminal before we turn over somebody else’s life into your hands.’ I don’t think it’s too much to ask that we have the same level of supervision for someone who takes over another human being’s life than we have for someone who deals potatoes in the state of Michigan. That’s a licensed profession in our state,” said Scott Teter, the Division Chief of the Financial Crimes Division at the Attorney General’s office and head of the AG’s Elder Abuse Task Force.

Attorney General Dana Nessel’s Elder Abuse Task Force has worked for 4 years on the legislation. She testified Wednesday that during her state-wide listening tour, she heard dozens of horror stories about probate court guardianships.

“Guardians moving someone from their home, sticking them in a nursing home, cleaning out their house, and throwing away all of their belongings-- tossing them in a dumpster-- and then immediately putting the house up for sale with no appraisal,” said Nessel. “The solution to these 73,000 incidences of elder abuse, neglect, and economic exploitation every year, the response should not be doing nothing.”

“We have in the lobby a freedom shrine, and it shows the Declaration of Independence. And I re-read it [today]: we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, they’re endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among them are life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. And there’s no qualifiers in there: ‘unless you get old, frail or your disabled,’” said Teter during the testimony.

The Michigan Guardianship Association still opposes the changes to the laws. There will be additional hearings on the bills in the coming weeks.


Full Article & Source:
Guardianship reform bills would put Office of State Guardian into place in Michigan

Michigan lawmakers seek new protections for guardian safety net

by  Craig Mauger

Lansing — Lawmakers announced Thursday they want to reform Michigan's guardianship system to prevent elder abuse in the wake of a Detroit News investigation that found mistreatment and lax oversight within the state's safety net for vulnerable adults.

A bipartisan group of senators is working on the new six bills that would require courts to obtain a physician or mental health professional’s assessment of an individual prior to appointing a guardian and would stipulate professional guardians be certified.

In Michigan, a court can appoint a guardian to supervise a person who loses the ability to take care of themselves. The professional guardian can manage a ward's finances, health care and other requirements of day-to-day living.

However, an 18-month Detroit News investigation, which debuted March 15, found there were no education, training or certification requirements for guardians and the legal framework was so devoid of protections that egregious financial conduct by guardians or conservators often was perfectly legal.

"This should not be happening in America, but it is happening every day in Michigan,” state Sen. Ruth Johnson, R-Holly, said. “Our current system is ripe for abuse, and there is not enough accountability or oversight.

"We’ve heard from too many victims and family members that reforms are badly needed.”

State Sen. Ruth Johnson has been pressing for guardianship reform legislation.  David Guralnick, The Detroit News

The News investigation showed guardians routinely placed elderly adults in care facilities and sold off their homes and possessions. One woman, Roberta Asplund of Ann Arbor, a retired public health nurse, had unsuccessfully sought to free herself from guardianship after she suffered a brain aneurysm in 2017.

In their announcement Thursday, Michigan lawmakers cited the reporting from The News and said they wanted to bring transparency to the state's guardianship system.

Their bills would require judges to explain specific reasons for appointing an unrelated professional guardian rather than a family member to oversee an individual’s care, according to a press release. Courts would also need to make video recordings of public court proceedings available.

The bills will be formally introduced and full details will become available when lawmakers return from a two-week spring break in April.

Tina Lindsay of Livonia, who became an activist for other families after successfully challenging guardianship for her father, hailed the reform effort Thursday.

"I really am hoping that this changes a lot of things for families," she told The News.

"I think the most important part of this legislation is that families are not kept away from their loved ones. And I hope before someone’s rights are taken away, they have an opportunity to be seen by a doctor because in a lot of these cases, these people are deemed incapacitated and they're not even seen.”

Sen. Paul Wojno, D-Warren, one of the sponsors of the package, said he wanted to ensure people's rights were protected.

"There is currently not enough oversight of guardians or conservators who manage the care and finances of thousands of Michigan seniors and other residents who might need some additional help, and we’ve seen multiple reports and heard directly from victims that the current system isn’t always working to protect them," Wojno said.

The bills are expected to be sent to the Senate Civil Rights, Judiciary, and Public Safety Committee for consideration. The panel is chaired by Sen. Stephanie Chang, D-Detroit, who is a co-sponsor.

The bills incorporate recommendations from Attorney General Dana Nessel’s Elder Abuse Task Force, which launched in 2019. The task force aimed to improve protections for wards when professional guardians sought to remove them from their homes and boost standards for medical reports that are used in guardianship hearings.

A related package of bills stalled in the Senate last session.

Full Article & Source:
Michigan lawmakers seek new protections for guardian safety net