Sunday, April 3, 2011

Jury Decides Richard Morse is Incapacitated

After a rare trial, a Clark County jury has found a Vancouver man incapacitated and unable to make decisions about his money and medical care.

Jurors deliberated for more than nine hours Thursday and Friday before deciding shortly after 1 p.m. Friday that a third-party professional guardian should be appointed to make financial and medical decisions on behalf of Richard Morse, 72. The jury’s ruling that Morse is incapacitated means they found him unable to provide for his safety and health and manage his finances.

The case was rare in that it was apparently the first time that 12 Clark County citizens were asked to decide a guardianship case, rather than a judge.

At least 10 jurors were required to find Morse incapacitated in order to strip him of his rights to make his own decisions. Morse preserved some of his rights, but the 10-juror requirement was met on all the “big ones,” said Morse’s attorney, Jim Senescu of Dimitrov & Senescu.

Addressing Superior Court Judge John Wulle, Senescu said immediately after the ruling, “I will explain to Mr. Morse he has essentially lost the rights the jury has voted on.”

One juror sided with Morse on all counts, while another joined to make it a 10-2 margin on some decisions over Morse’s fitness.

Senescu after the ruling returned to a point he made in his closing argument that Morse, a veteran of the Vietnam War, lost rights he once fought to preserve. “That says it all,” he said.

The unusual case was brought by Vancouver Health & Rehabilitation Center, where Morse has been living for more than a year. The center’s attorney, Rachel Brooks, argued during the four-day trial that Morse had problems living on his own and managing his medicine and his health.

Concerning his finances, Morse has a $600,000 estate yet never has had a bank account, Brooks argued, and he’s not used to paying bills.

Senescu said that Morse would appeal.

Specifically, a third-party guardian now will decide when and where Morse gets medical care. Financially, Morse cannot enter into a contract, engage in real estate transactions or sue or be sued.

Morse retained the right to vote, make or revoke a will, marry or divorce, drive a vehicle and make decisions regarding social aspects of his life.

A hearing was scheduled for 10:30 a.m. April 27 to decide on a guardian for Morse.

“I don’t think this is the end,” Morse said. “Now it’s up to the Lord.

Full Article and Source:
Guardianship Jury Finds Man, 72, Unable to Care for Self

See Also:
Jury Receives Rare Guardianship Case

72 Year Old Man Takes Guardianship Case to Jury


StandUp said...

This is a crying shame. They're saying he can't manage his money. Well, how did he accumulate $600K if he can't manage his money?

jerri said...

one interesting thing i noticed is that richard morse was not stripped of all of his rights which is what happens in the usa almost 100% of the time why? - very interesting and i took notice of that fact immediately now we will see how much the conservator will charge for his serviced and how long mr morse will keep many of his freedoms

Mike said...

I am so sorry for him. I believe the jurors didn't understand what they were doing to him.

Anonymous said...

One of the things victims want is a jury hearing. I am sorry to hear this hearing did not go his way.

Barbara said...

I'm shocked. I thought he had a chance with a jury. I will pray for Richard Morse.

Connie said...

I am shocked and disappointed.

Nancy said...

What a shame. They left him with some of his rights and he's supposed to feel good about that?

Anonymous said...

How can an incompetent person drive a car? There is something not right with that jury.