Showing posts with label Disbarment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Disbarment. Show all posts

Monday, March 23, 2026

Accused of Neglect: Connecticut conservator faces disbarment and lawsuits


by Alex Appel

Kristin Exner, a Connecticut lawyer and state-appointed conservator, made headlines last year when another attorney petitioned to have her disbarred. That petition followed two instances in which she sold houses owned by people whose estates she controlled to the co-owner of her real estate business. The houses were allegedly sold below market rate and then resold by her real estate company for a profit. 

The complaint was forwarded to a local grievance panel by the Statewide Bar Counsel’s Office on Feb. 26. In the meantime, Exner will not be appointed to manage new cases in the Milford-Orange Probate Court, according to court documents. 

In addition to that petition, court records show that three Connecticut nursing homes have accused Exner of neglecting eight people in conservatorships by failing to maintain their Medicaid benefits. These nursing homes have not received payments for care, one of Exner’s responsibilities as a conservator, allegedly shorting them almost $195,000, which they are seeking to recover via lawsuits.

Exner tells a different story. She calls these suits “baseless,” “frivolous,” and says they “have no merit.”  Court records show that the lawyer who filed the petition to have Exner disbarred has represented multiple people in suing Exner, and defended a woman who was ultimately removed from a conservatorship that Exner took over. 

This investigation provides an overview of the role of a conservator, a summary of the issues documented at the Norwalk-Wilton Probate Court, and the allegations made by nursing homes currently working their way through Connecticut’s judicial system.

An Appointed Power

A conservator is someone appointed by a probate court judge to oversee the personal or financial affairs of an incapacitated adult who is deemed incapable of competently managing on their own. According to a report published by Connecticut’s Probate Court Administrator Workgroup, conservators are most often relatives; however, if a court determines that an adult needs a conservator but cannot find a relative or close friend who is fit to manage that adult’s affairs, a judge may appoint a third-party lawyer.

That’s where Exner’s role as a state-appointed conservator comes in. 

Exner is one of hundreds of lawyers in the state whom judges appoint to manage conservatorships. Like other lawyers in this line of work, she is either paid by the conserved person via their financial assets or through a state fund. As is required by law, if she is working for a person with an estate, she charges an hourly rate for the work she does to manage the conservatorship and then submits the invoices to a probate judge for approval. Once the invoices are cleared, she can receive payment. 

If a person is indigent, Exner receives compensation through the Probate Court Administrative Fund, which has taxpayer money that is appropriated to the Judicial Department. In those instances, there is a flat rate of $90 a month, with an additional one-time payment of $1,300 to handle Medicaid applications, which her case files indicate is substantially less than what she charges in her private practice. 

Conservatorship can be controversial in Connecticut and across the country. In the past few years, there have been highly publicized instances of conservators abusing their power. 

There are even some high profile celebrities that were placed under conservatorships, including Britney Spears, whose parents allegedly forced her to have an IUD and prohibited her from getting married, former Beach Boys member Brian Wilson whose conservator Eugene Landy who gave him unnecessary psychiatric medication and had him monitored 24-7, and former NFL quarterback Michael Oher, the player who inspired “The Blind Side,” who claimed that his conservators lied to him to get him to sign away his rights by claiming he was being adopted. In all of these cases, the conservators extracted millions of dollars from the conserved people over the course of many years. 

But most instances of conservatorship abuse do not involve millionaires or celebrities. 

There are an estimated 1.5 million adults and $273 billion under the control of guardians or conservators in the United States.

“The extent of elder abuse by guardians [and conservatorship] nationally is unknown due to limited data on key factors related to elder abuse by a guardian, such as the numbers of guardians serving older adults, older adults in guardianships, and cases of elder abuse by a guardian,” a 2016 report from the federal Government Accountability Office (GAO) found. 

The lack of transparency and comprehensive understanding is, in part, due to a lack of comprehensive documentation of the various types of elder abuse committed by different types of guardians, including conservators. However, the GAO researchers did find indications that financial abuse is the most common form of elder abuse in guardianship. 

No one has accused Exner of abusing any of her conservatees, but she is facing multiple charges of negligence. Additionally, she is accused of selling two houses that were a part of estates she managed, including one that was in a conservatorship, to a man with whom she co-owned a real estate company.

Exner declined to comment on the house sales because they were a part of ongoing litigation. 

The Norwalk-Wilton Probate Court District

Inside Investigator reviewed the files for 16 open conservatorships Exner manages in the Norwalk-Wilton Probate Court District. This is not a comprehensive list of her conservatorship cases, and Exner did not respond to a question about how many conservatorships she is managing in total. 

Filings show that Exner charges $250 per hour for her services when she is managing someone who has an estate, and one of her paralegals charges $150 an hour. For one of the conserved people she is managing—a 72-year-old man with depression, benign prostatic hyperplasia, and who thinks he has dementia, even though his medical evaluations do not indicate that—her law firm was paid $13,800 for services rendered in a two-year period between April 2023 and May 2025.

That man’s files contain an email exchange between him and Exner during her annual check-in, and the notes from that check-in. According to those documents, both he and Exner are happy with the conservatorship arrangement. 

Some of her other cases are more complex.

Sometimes she made decisions that the conserved individual did not like. 

For example, Exner sold the house of one of the conserved persons under her care, against that woman’s wishes. The house in question had plumbing and structural issues, which the woman could not afford to fix, according to Exner’s report. Even though the woman was financially supporting her two adult sons, who lived in the house, prior to becoming conserved she had not paid her bills for months leading up to the sale. Finally, the home was facing foreclosure. Exner was appointed as the conservator, paid the bills, and by the time Exner sold the house, the woman had already moved in with her granddaughter.

Almost all of the people identified by Inside Investigator whose affairs Exner managed needed help managing their healthcare. All but three people under her care in the Norwalk-Wilton district suffered from dementia or severe mental illness when they were assigned a conservator. 

Of the three conserved people who Exner managed without dementia or documented mental illness, one of them was a brain-dead homeless man who was brought to Norwalk Hospital after he was discovered unconscious in a bush. He was on a ventilator for several weeks but was not responding to treatment. The staff at the Hospital could not find a living relative, nor any documentation that stated whether or not he wanted to be resuscitated. Hospital officials petitioned the court to appoint a conservator, who wound up being Exner, then advised Exner to tell them to take him off life support. She did.

The second was a woman who did not have any documented mental illnesses, but she was flagged for conservatorship when she refused medical treatment at a hospital. Exner was appointed to her case to get her medical treatment. According to filings in her conservatorship case, the Department of Children and Families (DCF) opened a case into that woman’s child because of suspected domestic violence. A Motion for Advice submitted by Exner states, “the Conservator has a reasonable belief of domestic violence and abuse in the home against (her), and that she is not capable of making decisions for her safety and well being.” 

The last person was a 79-year-old woman of sound mind who petitioned the court to voluntarily enter a conservatorship last year because she needed help re-applying for Medicaid. 

Even though Medicaid is legally guaranteed for people below a certain income threshold, it can be difficult to obtain. 

In 2012, a group of 5,000 Connecticut residents sued the Department of Social Services (DSS) for taking too long to process Medicaid applications. State law required most Medicaid applications to be processed within 45 days, but thousands of people had to wait longer. The class-action lawsuit was settled in 2014, and as a part of the settlement, the state had to commit to hiring 109 more people to help process applications and to process at least 92% of Medicaid and short-term care applications within the statutory timeframe by 2016. The state was given a two-year extension to meet that deadline, but fell behind. In 2018, only 85% of applications were processed on time.

Things turned around shortly after. By 2022, 98% of Medicaid applications were being processed within 24 hours of submission. However, submitting the application is only one step in the process. To get Medicaid for assisted living, a person needs to submit financial documents from the previous five years to prove they qualify for help. It can take months to gather the paperwork needed to apply for Medicaid.

While attorney fees vary, typically, the type of lawyer who practices elder law charges between $200 and $250 per hour.

The consequences for not obtaining Medicaid can be dire. 

There are only six reasons that a nursing home can evict a patient, and non-payment is one of them. A home is required to give residents 30 days’ notice before eviction, and a resident or their representative can appeal. These appeal processes can drag on for months, but at the end of the day, state officials cannot force a nursing home to continue to care for a nonpaying resident. 

The lawsuits against Exner show that homes will keep a resident despite months, and sometimes years, of non-payment. If a resident has a pending application for Medicaid, a nursing home legally cannot evict them. However, during this time, debt can accumulate. 

Sometimes, this debt can be paid retroactively from portions of the person’s estate. One of the nursing homes that is suing Exner is trying to access the estate of a deceased man whose conservatorship she managed. Since she was his legal representative in life, she is automatically listed as a defendant, even though she is no longer managing his estate. That man has a daughter, who is also being sued.

In the worst-case scenario, a resident is evicted. 

One of Exner’s conservatees was evicted from a nursing home in 2023, before she managed his case. The man, who had severe medical conditions, was homeless for a period of time and lived in various hospitals until Exner found a home where he could live. This conservatee was determined to be not of sound mind and couldn’t make decisions for himself.

Less than a year ago, Exner became a conservator of that 79-year-old woman who was of sound mind. When Inside Investigator reviewed the court records in mid-February, it was not clear if Exner had yet successfully helped the woman reapply for Medicaid. The records also did not contain any invoices.  The conserved person continued to live at the nursing home she resided in when she voluntarily asked to be placed under a conservatorship, Wilton Meadows Nursing & Rehabilitation in Wilton, until Feb. 9, according to a social worker at the center. She left the nursing home to live with her family.

The social worker said that Exner and her office were “nothing but excellent and responsive,” and “we had no issues or problems working with them.” 

But not every nursing home has had positive experiences with Exner. 

Nursing Home Allegations

Nursing Home Allegations

Inside Investigator found four lawsuits filed by nursing homes against Exner in the state of Connecticut. Three of them, which were all filed in 2023, are still ongoing. Those three each contain allegations that Exner neglected people under her care by mismanaging their Medicaid payments and applications. 

The three active lawsuits came from the Waterbury Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation, the West Haven Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation, and the Southport Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation. Together, these lawsuits allege Exner improperly managed Medicaid applications and payments made to eight senior citizens. 

All three lawsuits were filed by attorney Taruna Garg at Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law. Each lawsuit starts with a list of 19 identical lines outlining the responsibilities Exner had to ensure the people in her care had Medicaid, and why that was important. Then, it repeats those 19 lines when it outlines each “count” of negligence it accuses Exner of. In each lawsuit, there is one count per resident in Exner’s care.

“In connection with her appointment as conservator of the estate of the wards referenced herein,” each lawsuit states, “Exner has been granted both the duty and authority to enroll in, apply for, and claim benefits from federal or state benefit programs, including Medicaid. At all relevant times herein, Exner knew or should have known that public assistance would be required to cover the monthly cost of services provided by Plaintiff for the care, comfort, and maintenance of her wards, including lodging and meals. Exner was obligated to perform her duties within a reasonable time given the circumstances of each ward… Exner has failed to fulfill her statutory obligations to timely apply for and obtain benefits, among other actions, on behalf of her ward.”

Exner categorically denies these claims.

“Those allegations were part of frivolous lawsuits that have either been withdrawn or are in the process of being withdrawn, and are factually false,” Exner said in an email. “In every instance where I am appointed conservator, my sole priority is the welfare of the person to whom I have been appointed.”

Some of the claims made by the nursing homes have already been withdrawn. Each complaint was amended multiple times. All Centers removed Exner’s former employer, Gallo & Associates, LLC, as a defendant, modified language in the complaints, and made additional revisions to remove counts of neglect.

The Waterbury Center revised its initial complaint twice, in addition to removing Gallo & Associates as a defendant. It struck three counts of negligence and revised the alleged dollar amounts lost in one case. The nursing home initially calculated that a patient owed $112,000 in debt, but increased the estimated debt to $139,000.

The West Haven Center also made two revisions that each removed a single count of alleged neglect. The Southport Center also submitted two revisions that withdrew two counts of neglect. 

When withdrawing one count of neglect, the Southport center also withdrew an allegation that Exner transferred $100,000 from a resident’s bank account to her employer, and that she charged improper rates. 

Garg filed a separate lawsuit for each nursing home before combining the three into one lawsuit.

Online judicial records show that Garg filed for three extensions to provide evidence of these claims, and Exner applied for one extension of time to plead. Garg attempted to get a default decision against Exner for “failure to plead,” but that was rejected. 

Garg did not respond to questions.

“I have no comment on those cases,” Garg said.

But there are other records in the Norwalk probate files that indicate persistent problems with Exner.

In 2023, the Business Office Manager at the Southport Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation, Marcia Henry, emailed the probate court, asking Exner to be removed as the conservator of a resident mentioned in the lawsuit, although the allegation of neglect was later withdrawn. The email stated, “I have attempted to reach out to Attorney Exner on numerous occasions via calls to her office in which I would speak to [a] representative who would transfer to her voicemail with no return call. I have sent numerous emails with no response. (The resident Medicaid application) has been down since 07/19/2013 due to lack of supportive documents such as bank statements and [updated] gross pension benefits needed from the conservator. This is a serious matter now that the resident has no medical insurance coverage and owes the facility money.”

When asked about this email, Exner said, “[He] remains a client for whom I am serving as conservator, and we remain in regular contact. I was not familiar with those claims, but I can tell you based on my knowledge of the case that they are baseless.”

Exner has also had other issues with nursing homes. 

Another facility, the Mary Wade Home in New Haven, is suing Exner and the daughter of a deceased former resident, whose conservatorship Exner managed. The Mary Wade Home is accusing Exner of failing to get Medicaid for the conserved person and claimed that he owed them over $80,000 by the time he died. The Mary Wade Home filed the lawsuit to try to get some money from his estate, according to court filings.

The petition for discovery states that Exner was applying for Medicaid on behalf of the conservatee when he was admitted to the home, but that application was later denied. The complaint states that staff at the Mary Wade Home tried to collect payment for the year that he lived there, but no payments were sent. 

Exner say these claims are “incorrect.”

“His Medicaid application was not denied,” she wrote in an email. “As with all of my clients in which I am appointed conservator, my sole goal is to maintain their dignity, keep them safe and try and help them make their lives more livable. That was the case here as well.”

The Ludlow Center for Health and Rehabilitation also sued Exner, accusing her of failing to apply for Medicaid on behalf of a resident and, consequently, not paying the nursing home for their services. The home won a default judgment because she failed to plead. 

Garg has represented at least one other nursing home in a case against a different conservator, the Connecticut Judicial Branch’s online portal shows. In the lawsuit, the Plaintiff won a default judgment because the conservators failed to plead.

Damon Kirschbaum, the lawyer who filed for Exner to be disbarred, has had multiple run-ins with Exner. This includes one lawsuit where he represented a woman who was removed from a case that Exner took over. The former conservator, Rachel Menti, was initially designed by the conserved person himself. But she was removed when his family made numerous allegations of misconduct against her, and she was caught lying about her relationship with him to the staff at a hospital. Menti, who had no familial relationship to the man, told staff at a hospital that she was his daughter. 

Conclusion

None of the nursing homes who have sued Exner for negligence evicted the residents they claim owe them money. 

According to the most up-to-date court documents, the Southport nursing home calculates its current losses at around $36,454.85. The nursing homes in West Haven and Waterbury calculate their losses at around $20,000 and $139,000, respectively. 

The nursing homes’ court filings each accuse Exner of trying to remove residents from their care in response to their complaints.

Each of the three active lawsuits against Exner simultaneously claims that “harm and losses are anticipated to continue accruing” if the residents remain in their care, and that Exner is “retaliating” against them by moving residents out of the facilities “in an effort to cause additional harm.” Inside Investigator was not able to confirm the current addresses of the four residents listed in the lawsuit. 

Last year, Exner tried to persuade the Connecticut General Assembly to give conservators qualified immunity “for actions taken in good faith and in accordance with court orders,” according to a testimony she submitted. 

A Trial Management Conference for the three lawsuits filed by Garg is scheduled for the morning of November 10, 2026. If a settlement is not reached, the case will move to a jury trial. A jury selection date has already been set for November 19, 2026.

One of the lawsuits filed by Kirschbaum, in which his client is accusing Exner of mismanaging his mother’s estate when she was his conservator and selling her house to her business partner, has a hearing scheduled for the morning of Monday, March 23.

“This is an ongoing case and therefore I am unable to comment,” Exner said in an email. 

Full Article & Source:
Accused of Neglect: Connecticut conservator faces disbarment and lawsuits 

Sunday, June 19, 2022

SC Supreme Court summons disgraced lawyer Alex Murdaugh to appear in person on disbarment

By John Monk 


The South Carolina Supreme Court has summoned suspended Hampton County attorney Alex Murdaugh, who remains jailed in Richland County on a slew of financial charges, to its courtroom on June 22 to show cause why he should not be disbarred. 

In an order published Thursday, the high court in essence said that Murdaugh’s financial crimes are so great, and he has confessed to some of them, that it is a waste of the court’s investigative arm’s time and resources to investigate them any more. 

“Respondent shall appear in the Supreme Court Courtroom at 11:00 a.m. on June 22, 2022, to present legal argument on the question of whether this Court should disbar Respondent from the practice of law,” the court’s order said.

It was signed by Chief Justice Donald Beatty for all five justices. 

“In this unique case, (Murdaugh’s) admissions in the public record lead to only one conclusion — that (Murdaugh’s) egregious ethical misconduct subjects him to the most significant sanction available — disbarment. Accordingly, we find there is no need to expend additional resources to proceed through the normal disciplinary process,” the court’s order said.

Murdaugh’s attorney, Jim Griffin, said he doesn’t expect Murdaugh to contest the motion. He also said he expects Murdaugh to be there in person because the Supreme Court has also ordered a sheriff’s van to transport Murdaugh from the jail to the Supreme Court courtroom. 

If Murdaugh is disbarred because of this order, it means the public won’t get to see a full public accounting by the court of the extent of Murdaugh’s misdeeds and how he carried them out. 

Normally, the court’s investigative arm, called the Office of Disciplinary Council, conducts an investigation and after an in-depth process submits its findings for the court. The court then usually issues lengthy public findings of fact before taking serious disciplinary action. 

In a final order of disbarment, the Supreme Court could still issue findings of fact, but how detailed that document would be is open to question. 

State grand jury indictments issued last fall, winter and this spring charge Murdaugh with using sham bank accounts and con schemes to steal more than $8 million from his law firm, his clients and associates for a 12-year period.

But the indictments are only generally worded accusations and do not give the kind of details that would surface in a full-fledged Supreme Court investigation or a trial. 

“There is no factual dispute about whether (Murdaugh) engaged in dishonest conduct,” the court said. 

Murdaugh has been in the Richland County jail since last fall unable to post $7 million bond for his alleged financial crimes. It is one of the highest bonds ever set for a state criminal defendant. 

Murdaugh has appeared by remote video in previous hearings. In this case, however, the high court said it wanted him in its courtroom.


Full Article & Source:

Saturday, October 9, 2021

State Supreme Court orders disbarment of former Sewell attorney

by Jim Walsh

TRENTON - A former South Jersey attorney has been disbarred after a disciplinary panel called her "a detriment to the profession."

The state Supreme Court ordered the action against Stephanie Julia Brown, who formerly practiced in Sewell, after reviewing a 97-page report on seven complaints against her.

The report, prepared by the court's Disciplinary Review Board, asserted Brown "either refuses to provide, or is incapable of providing, her clients with even a rudimentary level of competent representation."

It also said Brown "has demonstrated a dangerous habit of undertaking the representation of vulnerable clients and utterly failing them, in some cases to their detriment, and lying to them."

And the report claimed Brown, who did not respond to the ethics charges against her in New Jersey, had "a long history of snubbing courts (and) disciplinary authorities."

Brown could not be reached for comment on the high court's Sept. 28 order.

The disciplinary board recommended disbarment for Brown, who received a law license in New Jersey in 2006 and in Pennsylvania two years earlier.

It noted she had been suspended from the practice of law in New Jersey since April 2019, and was previously disciplined in Pennsylvania.

Most of the allegations against Brown arose from the representation of clients seeking representation in U.S. Bankruptcy Court, the report said.

An account of one complaint noted a client's multiple efforts to obtain basic information about her bankruptcy filing.

"This was beyond dropping the ball," the client, Nicole Ferrara, wrote about Brown's performance in a letter cited by the report. "She lied about having my work completed and was unresponsive from the beginning."

Among other points, it said Brown failed to tell Ferrara that her bankruptcy action would allow her to recover a car that had been repossessed. She also incorrectly advised Ferrara to turn down a job, mistakenly saying the salary would exceed a level allowed under the bankruptcy filing.

One ethics complaint arose from Brown's guilty plea in March 2019 to charges of driving while intoxicated and driving during a license suspension for a previous DWI conviction.

The complaint alleged the conviction reflected "adversely" on Brown's honesty, trustworthiness or fitness as a lawyer.

"We are not unmindful of what appears to be (Brown's) serious substance abuse issue involving alcohol," said the report;

But it also noted "her inability or refusal to address this issue," as well as "the adverse consequences suffered by multiple clients … and her contemptuous conduct toward the courts."

As a result of those findings, the board said, "We reach the conclusion that she must be removed from the practice of law in order to protect the public and preserve confidence in the bar."

Full Article & Source:

Wednesday, April 10, 2019

One lawyer used client funds for Heat tickets, another was in a $3.25M scam. Then, trouble

The South Florida lawyers on the Florida Bar’s monthly discipline report include a convicted fraudster, both name partners of one law firm and an attorney who seems to have trouble putting things in writing.
Though the last two discipline reports from the Florida Bar included a relatively light combined total of 19 attorneys combined, the stories behind the disbarments and suspensions have a little more weight.

There’s at least over $1 million in “misappropriated funds,” some of which went to Heat tickets. Lawyers victimized by fraud and lawyers who participated in fraud. And attorneys who took the money and, if not ran, disappeared, at least professionally.

So, below in Part 1 are the alphabetical first 10 of the 19. The remaining nine will be in Part 2, which will post Monday.

▪ Golden Beach attorney Jeremy Alters, admitted 1997 out of UM School of Law, jumped in the deep end of trouble over improper transfers from Alters, Boldt, Brown, Rash and Culmo’s trust account to the operating account.

The Bar alleged that forty-nine such transfers occurred, totaling approximately $2,051,474.32, between September 2009 and December 2010. The Court approved the Bar’s Petition for Emergency Suspension and suspended Alters from the practice of law on December 28, 2011.

The Referee found that Alters should be reinstated because there was “no basis to conclude that Alters had made or authorized the improper transfers, and that no clients had been injured by the improper transfers.”

When the Florida Supreme Court reinstated Alters in January 2012, the Bar filed another complaint alleging Alters violated six Bar rules regarding the transfers. The Referee opined that Alters not be further sanctioned, but that he pay the Bar’s administrative costs ($1,250) while the Bar pays Alters’ legal defense costs ($143,913.35).

The Bar challenged everything in the Referee’s Report but the ink and asked the State Supreme Court to disbar Alters.

The Court found the Referee improperly excluded evidence that Alters lied about his personal tax status and called the Referee’s Report “inadequate.” Not only did the Court find the Referee came to “only the most basic conclusions from the summarized testimony, and oftentimes has failed to make any findings regarding undisputed evidence in the case,” but noted the findings of fact were only four pages of the 71-page report.

“It is inconceivable that the facts of such a complicated case, which has taken years to litigate and the record of which spans thousands of pages, could be reduced to four pages.”

The Court ultimately found that Alters misappropriated client funds and “must be disbarred.”

The Bar’s auditor testified at the final hearing before the Referee that in addition to funds slid straight to Alters, he used trust fund money to cover firm expenses and overdrafts and personal expenses. Among those personal expenses: Miami Heat tickets.

▪ Orlando’s Elizabeth Anderson, a Stetson Law School graduate admitted in 2003, Stetson, has been suspended since Nov. 7 for trust account shortages of $160,000, most of which were in two accounts.

A bar audit found a shortage of $37,000 in the trust account at Seaside Bank that The Anderson Law Group used for matters involving Stoneybrook West Master Association.

“During her sworn statement on August 1, 2018, respondent admitted to the shortage in her Seaside trust account and stated that she would not have been able to pay the balances she owed to Stoneybrook without obtaining either the loan from her parents or using funds from her retirement account.”

The Bar’s audit also revealed that there was a shortage of at least $122,330.62 in another trust account at Fairwinds Credit Union.

From this account, the Bar says in its Petition for Emergency Suspension, she used settlement funds for a client to office rent, rent, herself, American Express, and Florida Lawyers Mutual.
▪ John Borland of Ocala started his suspension Dec. 28, but seems like he suspended his law career well before that. The Bar says Borland abandoned his law practice, client files, fell behind in his Bar fees and continuing legal education credits and then ignored Bar inquiries about all this. The Florida Coastal School of Law had been a Bar member since 2006.
John Borland.jpg
John Borland The Florida Bar
▪ Aldo Busot of Coral Gables has been disbarred. In handling a suit to collect a promissory note, Busot neglected his duties, missed deadlines and kept his client ignorant of the case’s progression. She learned he filed for voluntary dismissal from a friend. Busot was suspended for three years on April 19.

When Busot didn’t submit an affidavit with the clients, tribunals and opposing lawyers notified of his suspension and the names and addresses of people and businesses that got a copy of his suspension order, the Cal Berkeley School of Law graduate was found in contempt and disbarred. He’d been a member since 1987.

▪ West Palm Beach attorney Richard Carey, a Bar member since 2009 out of the University of Pittsburgh’s law school, served a 10-day suspension in December. According to Carey’s guilty plea, non-lawyers at his Pinnacle Land and Title handled a real estate sale that involved a fraudulent court order. Carey said he was on vacation at the time. He tried to rectify matters upon hearing of the problem and eventually reached a settlement with the harmed party.

▪ Miami’s Robert Dixon’s 90-day suspension in May for mishandling his trust account and suffering a shortage in trust funds required he produce trust account records from July 2015 to the present. The University of Florida School of Law graduate, a Bar member since 2006, needed to do this by June 24. Dixon came across with records June 25 that the Bar’s auditor found a day late and several dollars short of accuracy — checks that had cleared listed as outstanding, deposits that had cleared listed as not having cleared. For this failure, Dixon received a public reprimand.

▪ John Eagen of Tallahassee, a Florida State law school man and Bar member since 1990, served a 30-days suspension that ended Jan. 7. Eagen continued to represent a defendant in Volusia County in January 2017 despite being ineligible to practice law. This got revealed after he failed to show up for a scheduled hearing and didn’t tell the judge of his status, even as the judge asked repeatedly over the phone, “Is there anything else you want to tell me?”

Eagen was ineligible because he was delinquent paying $2,500 restitution from a previous Bar discipline case involving how he charged a client.

▪ Peter Fellows of Miami has been disbarred for a conflict of interest in a case involving his baby’s mother and, in a separate matter, lying to Bar investigators. Fellows cases were detailed in this Miami Herald story.

Full Article & Source:
One lawyer used client funds for Heat tickets, another was in a $3.25M scam. Then, trouble

Wednesday, October 24, 2018

Hundreds of Stan Chesley's former clients get $23.5 million settlement in fen-phen case

Attorney Stan Chesley
CINCINNATI - Years after hundreds of Stan Chesley’s clients sued to recover money he allegedly stole from their diet drug case, a federal judge announced a $23.5 million settlement on Wednesday.

In a few days the 382 victims of a fen-phen lawsuit filed two decades ago will finally receive money that their attorneys allegedly skimmed from their settlement with the drug maker.

“Some of them had such significant health problems because of the drug; they did lose everything,” said Lexington attorney Angela Ford. “Nearly all of them have had some degree of loss of faith in the justice system … I ran out of excuses to give them years ago for the case dragging on and moving in so many different directions.”

The settlement puts an end to the federal case against Chesley’s former law firm, Waite Schneider Bayless & Chesley, which harbored many of Chesley’s assets after he was disbarred in 2013. It also dismisses eight other related state court cases.

The settlement removes any future claims against Chesley’s wife, U.S. District Judge Susan Dlott, for assets she may have received from her husband.

But the settlement does not end the federal case, or any state lawsuit, against Chesley individually.
“None of these actions have changed his conduct, or his demeanor, or his sense of responsibility for the people he stole from,” Ford said.

In June the federal Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati issued a scathing rebuke of Chesley and his “scheme” to avoid paying a $42 million judgment dating back four years.

“For years … Stanley Chesley appears to have been orchestrating a high-stakes shell game in an effort to escape a long-overdue multi-million dollar judgment. In the process, he has defrauded hundreds of judgment creditors, many of who are plaintiffs here,” judges wrote in the opinion.

A Kentucky state court issued a judgment nearly four years ago against Chesley for $42 million he owed his former clients. Since then, those victims have been trying to collect.

U.S. District Judge Robert Cleland, a visiting judge from Michigan, approved a settlement this week, which finally makes them whole on that $42 million debt. But they are still owed tens of millions in long-overdue interest on that money, Ford said.

“Chesley has been successfully evading them with the help of his confidantes. In the process, five lawyers have been disbarred; two have been put in jail,” the appeals court wrote. “Through it all, Chesley has managed to transfer most of his assets elsewhere rendering himself judgment-proof.”

An attorney for Chesley did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The story behind the case began in 1998 when Chesley joined three attorneys in a class-action lawsuit against American Home Products, the maker of the diet drug fen-phen. In 2001, attorneys negotiated a settlement of more than $200 million, for injuries to their clients from the drug’s side effects. The drug maker left it up to the lawyers to divvy up the settlement.

“So the fraud began,” the appeals court wrote. “The lawyers, at least for the time being, made out like bandits.”

The fallout from the scheme has been sweeping. Five lawyers and a judge have been permanently disbarred. Two of Chesley’s accomplices were convicted of wire fraud and are serving prison time.

Chesley avoided prosecution by testifying against his co-counsel, according to the appeals order.

After years of trying to collect their judgment in state court, the victims filed a federal suit in 2016 to unwind the assets that Chesley had transferred to his law firm and a trust set up by another attorney, Thomas Rehme.

As part of the settlement, a federal judge issued a permanent injunction freezing those assets and preventing Chesley from ever receiving them.

In May 2017, many of Chesley’s former clients traveled to Cincinnati to protest outside of the Hamilton County Courthouse.

“There’s some of us who are going to die before this is all over with and I might be one of them,” Evelyn Hopkins, of Florida, told reporters then. “It’s destroyed me, it’s destroyed my family.”

Hopkins, who has a pacemaker, stents in her heart and a leaky heart valve caused by the diet drug, lost her home and had to move in with her daughter.

“It wouldn’t hurt him to pay us and he probably wouldn’t even miss it, he’s got so much,” Hopkins said. “I live with my daughter. I live in a bedroom because I can’t afford anything else. I’m on food stamps.”

The $22.5 million settlement will be distributed to victims based on the amounts that were stolen from them in the original fen-phen settlement, Ford said.

“The door is open to collect additional money from him (Chesley),” Ford said.

Connie Centers, a victim from Kentucky, told reporters that some have died awaiting their settlement money.

“Our lives have been destroyed … all this time they’re spending this money on filing this appeal and this appeal, paying out all these fees,” Centers said. “And we’re living in poverty, we can’t pay our bills, can’t get our medicines because of our heart problems. It can’t go on, it has just got to stop.

“The judicial system, I used to believe in it. The judicial system now, I have no faith in it. I’ve lost it for 17 years."

Full Article & Source:
Hundreds of Stan Chesley's former clients get $23.5 million settlement in fen-phen case

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

Civil and criminal penalties sought against Beaumont attorney


Beaumont attorney Alto Watson III is facing both criminal charges for burglary and possible disbarment for stealing from his former firm and client.

As previously reported, the Commission for Lawyer Discipline, an arm of the State Bar of Texas,
Alto Watson III
filed a disciplinary petition against Watson on May 31 in Jefferson County District Court.

According to the Beaumont Enterprise, on May 22 Watson was arrested for burglary of a habitation and family violence. He has since been indicted.

The commission’s petition says that from September 1998 through July 8, 2012, the Law Firm of

Gilbert T. Adams employed Watson. During his employment, the suit alleges Watson wrongfully billed clients separately for his services and personally accepted client funds meant for the firm, depositing the money in his personal accounts for his own use and benefit.

For example, the suit claims that on March 2, 2011, Mohd Ali hired the firm for representation in a suit styled Major League Grill Franchise vs. Azam Beaumont Enterprises. Ali agreed to pay the firm $10,000 — $5,000 of which Watson asked the client to pay directly to him. He deposited the funds into his personal account and failed to inform the firm, according to the lawsuit.


Full Article and Source:
Civil and criminal penalties sought against Beaumont attorney