Life Care Center of Plainwell, Mich., which sent a resident to a psychiatric hospital this year.Credit...Nick Hagen for The New York Times
By Jessica Silver-Greenberg and Rachel Abrams
In a New York nursing home, a resident hurled a bingo chip. At a home in Georgia, a 46-year-old woman, paralyzed from the waist down, repeatedly complained that no one had changed her diaper. In a California facility, a patient threw tableware.
In all three cases, the nursing homes cited the incidents as a reason to send the residents to hospitals for psychiatric evaluations — and then to bar them from returning.
Across the United States, nursing homes are looking to get rid of unprofitable patients — primarily those who are poor and require extra care — and pouncing on minor outbursts to justify evicting them to emergency rooms or psychiatric hospitals. After the hospitals discharge the patients, often in a matter of hours, the nursing homes refuse them re-entry, according to court filings, government-funded watchdogs in 16 states, and more than 60 lawyers, nursing home employees and doctors.
The practice at times violates federal laws that restrict nursing homes from abruptly evicting patients.
“Even before the pandemic, there was tremendous pressure to get rid of Medicaid patients, especially those that need high levels of staffing,” said Mike Wasserman, a former chief executive of Rockport Healthcare Services, which manages California’s largest chain of for-profit nursing homes. “The pandemic has basically supercharged that.” He said homes often take advantage of fits of anger to oust patients, claiming they need psychiatric care.
About 70 percent of American nursing homes are for profit. The most lucrative patients are those on short-term rehabilitation stints paid for by private insurers or Medicare, the federal program that insures seniors and people with disabilities. Poor people on longer-term stays are covered by Medicaid, which reimburses nursing homes at a much lower rate than Medicare.
The financial incentive to have more Medicare or privately insured patients, and fewer on Medicaid, becomes more pronounced when the Medicaid patients have illnesses, like dementia, that require extra care from staff.
Nursing homes have faced acute staff shortages as the coronavirus has left employees sick or afraid to go in to work. Workers said they faced increased pressure from their employers during the pandemic to get rid of the most expensive, least lucrative patients.
Invoking psychiatric problems is a popular tool. Nursing homes routinely admit patients with dementia, Alzheimer’s or similar illnesses, and angry outbursts are common.
Evon Smith with the memorial book of her mother, Joan Rivers.Credit...Alexis Hunley for The New York Times
In March, the Rehabilitation Center of Santa Monica, Calif., sent Joan Rivers, who suffered from dementia and was on Medicaid, to the emergency room at USC Verdugo Hills Hospital. The nursing home’s staff said Ms. Rivers, 87, had tossed aside her chair, scaring other residents, according to her daughter, Evon Smith, and a government-funded watchdog.
Within 24 hours, the hospital cleared her for discharge.
Ms.
Smith said that she had repeatedly asked the Rehabilitation Center to
take her mother back, but that it had refused. A social worker at
Verdugo Hills said she, too, had tried unsuccessfully to get the nursing
home to readmit Ms. Rivers.
Linda
Taetz, the chief compliance officer at Mariner Health Care, which
operates the Rehabilitation Center and 19 other nursing homes in
California, said the center hadn’t known that Ms. Rivers wanted to
return.
Ms. Rivers eventually was
admitted to the Colonial Care Center nursing home in Long Beach, Calif.
There, she contracted Covid-19. She died on July 20.
Federal
law requires nursing homes to follow strict guidelines when they intend
to evict someone: They must give 30 days’ notice and come up with a
plan to transfer the resident to a facility that can meet his or her
needs. If a resident goes to a hospital, the facility must hold the bed
for a week.
But nursing homes
frequently flout these rules, according to employees and state-funded
ombudsmen who help oversee the industry. The New York Times reported in July
that nursing homes were evicting an increasing number of low-income —
and therefore low-profitability — residents into homeless shelters and
run-down motels, apparently in violation of federal law.
There is no national data on nursing home evictions. The Times contacted ombudsmen in all 50 states.
Some said they had not seen nursing homes dumping patients in hospitals during the pandemic. But in 16 states, including California, Texas and New York, ombudsmen said the problem was continuing. Some said they believed it was getting worse.
“We have been seeing these kinds of illegal discharges all the time, because nursing homes seem to have figured out that they will rarely, if ever, be penalized,” said Alison Hirschel, senior legal counsel to the Michigan ombudsman program. “It’s devastating for residents and their families all the time, but especially horrible and dangerous during a pandemic.”
Ms. Rivers contracted Covid-19 while staying at the Colonial Care Center in Long Beach, Calif.Credit...Alexis Hunley for The New York Times
Medicaid patients who require lots of staff attention “have a target on their back,” she said.
The problem predates the pandemic.
Gloria Single was a resident of the Pioneer House nursing home in Sacramento. She had dementia and pulmonary disease and was on California’s version of Medicaid. Pioneer House was receiving about $400 a day for her care.
In 2017, Ms. Single got upset and threw utensils, according to a lawsuit against Pioneer House filed in state court by Ms. Single’s lawyer. The nursing home called 911, and Ms. Single was taken to a hospital for an involuntary psychiatric hold, in which patients are held until they are determined not to be a danger to themselves or others. The hospital determined later that day that there was nothing wrong with Ms. Single aside from her pre-existing dementia.
But Pioneer House would not let her return. The California Department of Health Care Services concluded that Pioneer House had violated the law and ordered it to let her go back. The home still refused. After about five months at the hospital, Ms. Single was moved to another nursing home. She died last year.
“You can get $1,000 extra a day by getting rid of the Gloria Singles of the world and replacing them with someone on Medicare,” said Matthew Borden, Ms. Single’s lawyer.
John Supple, a lawyer for the Retirement Housing Foundation, which operates Pioneer House, said that its medical director had deemed the home unsuitable for Ms. Single’s medical needs and that Pioneer House had never received the medical records it needed to readmit her. (Ms. Single’s lawyer disputes that. The lawsuit is ongoing.) Mr. Supple said Pioneer House had held Ms. Single’s bed for months and had not replaced her with a Medicare patient.
During the pandemic, nursing homes in Illinois and Michigan have repeatedly sent elderly and disabled Medicaid patients to NeuroBehavioral Hospital in Crown Point, Ind., said Kimberly Jackson, a discharge planner at the psychiatric hospital. In one case, a resident who yelled at a staff member was branded as being violent and having a psychotic break.
“The homes seem to be purposely taking symptoms of dementia as evidence of psychosis,” Ms. Jackson said. (Christy Gilbert, the chief operating officer of the hospital’s parent company, said instances when nursing homes dumped patients in her company’s hospitals were “very few and far between.”)
In June, Life Care Center of Plainwell, Mich., sent Nicki Safapour, a Medicaid patient who needs a wheelchair, to NeuroBehavioral Hospital. Because of a developmental disability, Mr. Safapour, 55, has the mental capacity of a 5-year-old, according to his brother John, who is his legal guardian. He said Life Care had told him that Mr. Safapour assaulted an employee and another resident.
A state health inspector later determined that the discharge was illegal, according to a copy of the inspector’s report reviewed by The Times.
“It seemed like they were just trying to get rid of Nicki,” John Safapour said. “He took up a lot of staff time.”
A spokesman for Life Care, Davis Lundy, said that privacy rules prohibited him from discussing Mr. Safapour’s case, but that Life Care had a significant number of residents on Medicaid and that “we never discharge patients based on their payer source.”
Nicki Safapour, as his wheelchair was strapped into a van, was illegally evicted from a nursing home in June, a government agency found.Credit...Nick Hagen for The New York Times
The families of some evicted patients have had to take them into their homes, although they lack the training or equipment to care for them.
In June, Connie Rodina got a phone call from the Richmond Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center in Richmond, Kan. Her 63-year-old brother, Jon Fowler, who suffers from mental illness and dementia, had hit another resident. Ms. Rodina, her brother’s guardian, was told that she needed to pick him up immediately.
By the time Ms. Rodina arrived, Mr. Fowler was already being transported to an emergency room. The hospital was ready to discharge him a couple of days later, after treating him for a urinary tract infection. Ms. Rodina said Richmond Healthcare wouldn’t take him back.
“You can’t just put somebody out like that,” said Camille Russell, a regional ombudsman who filed a complaint against the facility with the Kansas Department for Aging and Disability Services. The complaint is pending, she said.
Ms. Rodina couldn’t find another nursing home that would admit Mr. Fowler, who needs near-constant care. After her brother had been in the hospital for weeks, she reluctantly moved him into her home.
“It’s basically taken my life away from me,” Ms. Rodina said. “It’s impossible for me to care for him.”
Representatives of Richmond Healthcare didn’t respond to requests for comment.
In some cases, nursing homes have ignored orders from regulators to take back patients they sent to emergency rooms or psychiatric hospitals.
Charles Borden, a stroke victim with dementia, had been staying at the skilled nursing facility at Tahoe Forest Hospital in Truckee, Calif. Medicaid was covering his long-term stay. But in April, after Mr. Borden elbowed a nursing assistant and cursed at her, the nursing home sent him to the hospital’s emergency room for a psychiatric evaluation.
Within hours, the emergency room cleared Mr. Borden to return to the nursing home. But it wouldn’t take him back, according to court records. (While the nursing home and the main Tahoe Forest hospital share a campus and are owned by the same organization, the nursing home is financially independent from the hospital.)
Later that day, the nursing home dropped off all of Mr. Borden’s possessions at the E.R. and moved another resident into the room that Mr. Borden had shared with his wife, Beverly.
Two days later, on April 22, Mr. Borden’s son appealed the decision to California’s health care agency. It determined that the nursing home was legally required to take Mr. Borden back. The nursing home refused.
The state agency said it had no authority to force the nursing home to let Mr. Borden return, aside from fining it $50 for every day it refused.
Matt Mushet, a lawyer for the nursing home, said it “is committed to the optimal safety of all patients and team members.” He said that he couldn’t comment on Mr. Borden’s case but that “it’s important for the public to understand there is more than one side to this story.”
Mr. Borden has spent the past five months marooned in the hospital. His dementia makes it hard for him to understand what is going on, his son said, but Mr. Borden asks every day to see his wife.
FORT MYERS — When grandparents reach the end of their lives, many
families don’t have the time or resources to take care of them. That’s
why many choose to assign a professional guardian to take care of them,
but sometimes, that decision can go horribly wrong. We spoke to a Cape
Coral woman who said her grandmother was stolen from her in a court of
law, and we’re also hearing from a state senator trying to keep it from
happening to others.
Today, all that Angela Fagg has left of her grandmother can now fit on her kitchen table.
“I
feel like it’s all my fault. I honestly do feel like it’s all my fault.
Because I wasn’t smart enough to be able to protect my grandma," said
Fagg.
Fagg’s grandma, Clara Apseloff, had Alzheimer’s. She was
declared infirm, and although Fagg tried to become her legal guardian in
court, she didn’t have a lawyer. The judge assigned her grandmother a
professional guardian instead.
“We’re walking out, and my grandma
is kind of happy and I’m like grandma, it’s okay, and she’s okay and I
get to go home with you now. Is that what’s happening? And I said no
grandma, you don’t get to go home with me, you’re going back to the
facility. I’m not in charge of you anymore. And she cried," said Fagg.
Fagg
said, as soon as the guardian had control, things got worse. The
doctors stopped talking to her. The nurses wouldn’t allow her to take
her grandmother out of the nursing home. Then came the real shock.
“I was told she was running out of money. My grandmother shouldn’t have been running out of money," said Fagg.
Fagg’s
grandmother was living at the Palms Senior Living Community in Fort
Myers, until she stopped paying rent, and the Palms thinks, that wasn’t
her fault, it was her guardian’s. According to a lawsuit, filed by the
Palms back in October, the company believes the guardian made up the
company she said she worked for, and mismanaged Apseloff’s finances to
the point she owed the Palms more than $25,000.
“She was evicted, at 99 years old," said Fagg.
Now,
a bill in the legislature, sponsored by State Senator Kathleen
Passidomo, is trying to keep this from happening to anyone else.
“The
bill prohibits a guardian from petitioning for their own appointment,
unless they’re a relative, because we have heard of cases where
professional guardians have basically trolled nursing homes and looked
for victims," said Passidomo.
Last week was Apseloff’s funeral. Fagg was only notified an hour after she died, and didn’t even get to plan the ceremony.
“I
just don’t understand how somebody could take something so precious.
It’s the end of our life. It’s families that get to do these things, not
some stranger," said Fagg.
Senator Passidomo said cases like Fagg’s are becoming more common. Her
bill would also prevent guardians from issuing do not resuscitate orders
without court approval.
Dozens of residents of an independent living community in Manhattan —
some as old as 99 — are being forced out of the homes they thought
they’d die in.
Residents of the Riverview Senior Residence in Manhattan.Credit...Photographs by Karsten Moran for The New York Times
By Sharon Otterman
Gabrielle Wagner, 91, moved into the Riverview Senior Independent Living
facility last April after her identical twin, whom she had lived with,
died in 2018. She had been lonely and the modern apartment tower in
Hell’s Kitchen felt less like assisted living and more like a
comfortable community for active seniors where she could live out her
days.
“I thought I’d go out feet
first,” she said just before Christmas. “I thought I’d finally found a
place I can stay in until I die.”
Muriel
Fisher, 86, left her $811-a-month, rent-controlled, two-bedroom
apartment in Jackson Heights, Queens, to move in to a studio at the
Riverview in 2018. Her grandson, who lives on the same Manhattan block
as the center, insisted it was no longer safe for her to be alone.
Milton
Gluck, also 86, moved in three months ago to be closer to his son,
after his partner of 30 years entered a nursing home. He hasn’t yet
fully unpacked.
Then, on Dec. 3, the building’s
management distributed a surprise letter to all the residents. Riverview
was being sold, it said, “sometime in the first few months of 2020.”
Everyone would have to leave.
The
nonprofit that owns the building said the center, which opened less than
two years ago, had been losing money and it could no longer afford to
run it. The group was seeking a market-rate buyer.
The
news sent the 31 residents of Riverview — who are nearly all in their
70s, 80s and 90s — into a panic, unsure of where they would go.
New
York City is in the grips of an affordable housing crunch for seniors —
the latest data shows an estimated 200,000 low-income seniors were on
waiting lists for federally subsidized housing in 2016 citywide — and
middle-income seniors are also struggling to find homes that fit their
needs.
A banner reading “Now Available Senior Residence” can be seen at the top of the facade of the Riverview Senior Residence.
At
the high end, there are luxury independent living options in Manhattan
like the Atria on West 86th Street, where fees soar to over $11,000 a month for a one-bedroom, and the Inspir, an even more expensive option opening on the Upper East Side.
For older New
Yorkers in the middle — even those who can afford Riverview’s rates of
about $4,000 a month for a small apartment, three meals a day,
housekeeping and some social events — the options are limited. And when
you’re a nonagenarian looking for what may be your last home, it’s not
just about finding an open spot.
The EastView,
a new independent living facility that the Salvation Army just opened
in Harlem, has space, but many residents felt it was too far from their
families. The West 74th Street Residence, which has interviewed several Riverview residents, was less expensive, but had less charm, some said.
Nothing
felt like the Riverview, a 14-story building at 49th Street and 10th
Avenue in the heart of Midtown. Several residents described falling in
love with its hotel-like hallways, modern finishes and Hudson River
views. So its residents, many using pensions from careers as educators,
engineers or public servants, sold homes, left friends and moved in.
For Stuart Dunn,
90, it was the second time that his senior living landlord was asking
him to move in order to sell the property. Until 2018, he lived in the
Williams on the Upper West Side, a Salvation Army-owned independent
living residence that was closed to make way for luxury housing.
“It
is a societal issue that we really are at the cutting edge of,” he
said, of the difficulty of finding a quality place to live with other
independent seniors. “What is society going to do about the elderly?”
He said he most feared losing contact with his fellow residents, particularly Ms. Fisher, with whom he had become very close.
Muriel Fisher sitting in her apartment at the Riverview Senior Residence on Dec. 19, 2019.Credit...Karsten Moran for The New York Times
Some residents are meeting with lawyers to see what else can be done. About five have already moved out.
One
has died, and another, who has been in the hospital, has not been able
to deal with the news completely. “They are fearful of what is going to
happen, and overwhelmed,” Joel Riff, 68, who is among the younger
residents. “The mood is pretty depressed.”
They
were particularly surprised, they said, because Riverview is owned by a
nonprofit corporation that largely operates homeless shelters, Homes for the Homeless.
After losing its city contract to run the building as a family homeless
shelter in 2015, the organization decided to renovate and reopen the
facility as an independent living building in early 2018, said Ralph da Costa Nunez, the chief executive officer of Homes for the Homeless.
The
organization had succeeded with a similar conversion in Staten Island,
and thought it could do the same in Manhattan. But Riverview never
filled more than 35 or so of its 82 apartments, he said.
The
residents felt that Riverview had not adequately marketed itself. Some
said that they knew seniors who had reached out to explore moving in,
but that the management had not followed up with them. Mr. da Costa
Nunez disputed that account. He said there were likely not enough
interested residents because Riverview did not offer assisted living
services, and some families wanted the option of more comprehensive care
as their family members aged.
Assisted living
centers are regulated by the New York Department of Health, which
provides additional protections to residents. But the Riverview, though
it marketed itself as a place where seniors could bring private aides,
had no such designation. As a result, the seniors, who had only
month-to-month contracts, were vulnerable to eviction.
Mr.
da Costa Nunez said that his organization could no longer afford to run
the facility at a loss. “We are getting killed” with the costs of food,
staffing and utilities, he said, adding that part of the issue was that
the seniors were keeping the heat too high.
The
losses, which he said amounted to “several million dollars already,”
had started to threaten the operation of the senior facility in Staten
Island, he said.
“No one wants to shut
this down,” he said, “but Economics 101 is Economics 101.” He added
that the closure “won’t happen before April for sure,” though the
management had not stated the same in writing to the residents.
As the losses spiraled, residents said, the nonprofit
repeatedly reassured its tenants not to worry and kept signing new
contracts. Among the most fragile residents are a 99-year-old Holocaust
survivor, who has no family and is looked after by an organization, Selfhelp Community Services, and Mildred Burt, 95, who arrived in March at the urging of a niece.
Ms.
Burt had come from a public-housing project where she had lived for 60
years. Her niece, Pat Jackson, said: “Where does that leave me? With an
aunt who is 95 years old who is basically homeless, and not much time to
look. This is just heartless.”
Determined
to fight back, the seniors formed a committee and contacted their
elected officials. Five local elected officials signed a joint letter to
Mr. da Costa Nunez demanding more time and support to the displaced
seniors.
“They
are slipping through the regulatory framework,” said State Senator Brad
Hoylman, who represents the area, vowing to look into the matter
further. “That seems to be duplicitous.”
Mr.
Nunez himself earned over $620,000 in 2018 as the director of Homes for
the Homeless and its nonprofit affiliates, according to tax documents.
At a heated meeting with elected officials on Dec. 19, he claimed to be
surprised by the angry reaction to the closure and “questioned why
these seniors can’t fend for themselves,” Mr. Hoylman recalled.
As the issue gained
attention, Riverview sent residents a follow-up letter on Dec. 20,
saying that the building would “likely” not be sold until April.
“No one is being thrown out,” the letter said.
Gabriel Wagner, 91, reads in her apartment at the Riverview Senior Residence.Credit...Karsten Moran for The New York Times
“We
are going to run the place until we can transition every person out of
there appropriately,” Mr. Nunez said in the interview.
Amid
the uncertainty, the seniors have begun to plan their next steps. Both
Mr. Dunn and Ms. Fisher have put deposits down at the Carnegie East
House on East 96th Street, where assisted-living studios with meals
start at $6,400 a month, a stretch for them. Ms. Wagner is moving March 1
to the EastView in Harlem, selling some of her furniture to do so.
“Luckily for me, I was a Navy wife, so I know what moving is all about,” she said. “Not that I am looking forward to it.”