Sunday, March 13, 2016

In Appreciation of Senator Todd Weiler and Representative Tom Hawkes of Utah and Senator Rusty Crowe of Tennessee

Senator Todd Weiler and Representative Tom Hawkes as SB 111 passed! 
Senator Weiler’s hard work to pass SB 111 in Utah speaks to the exemplary job he is doing for the people of his state. It was a privilege to work with him on SB 111. The excitement we share with the first passing of Falk/NASGA’s human and personal rights for guardianship and conservatorship wards is echoed by reform advocates across the country in anticipation of our bill coming to their individual states.

We must also recognize Senator Rusty Crowe of Tennessee and give him due credit for our success in Utah.  Our bill was originally drafted in Tennessee, working with Senator Rusty Crowe and his bill drafter/attorney who gave Catherine Falk and NASGA the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to address the growing and insidious problem of wrongful isolation of guardianship wards by their court-appointed guardians/conservators by crafting a bill from scratch. It was a team effort in every sense of the word and we are proud that our bill empowers wards, increases court oversight, and provides means of accountability to unscrupulous guardians who wield isolation as a means of retaliation, control, or just convenience.

Different states have different laws; and each state must comport their proposed legislation to fit existing law. Senator Weiler quickly recognized the intention and merit of our bill for his state; and he and his team took much of the language of our Tennessee bill for SB 111 which was passed last Thursday.

We are proud of SB 111 and forever grateful to Senator Weiler and Representative Tom Hawkes for believing in our bill and for the dedication and hard work they both invested in getting it passed.

Falk/NASGA will always be grateful to these three superb statesmen for their support and enthusiasm for our mission and our bill.

Whistleblower Lawyers Counterattack Against DC Disciplinary Counsel


The DC Disciplinary Counsel — previously known as the DC Bar Counsel — is on the attack against whistleblower lawyers.

And whistleblower lawyers are not happy about it. They have launched something of a counterattack.

The Disciplinary Counsel has filed charges against prominent Washington whistleblower lawyer Lynne Bernabei and former Justice Department attorney Thomas Tamm.

Tom Divine
The Disciplinary Counsel brought charges in June 2014 against Bernabei and
Notre Dame Law Professor G. Robert Blakey — alleging that the two advised their client — former General Electric lawyer and whistleblower Adriana Koeck — to go public to reporters and law enforcement officials in the United States with incriminating and alleged confidential information against General Electric.

The case was initiated with a complaint filed by General Electric with the Disciplinary Counsel against Koeck.

In November 2015, Blakey was given the mildest possible sanction in the District — an admonition. The cases against Koeck and Bernabei are pending.

Last month, Tamm was charged with calling a reporter from a pay phone to make public the federal government’s program of illegal wiretapping.

Now, the whistleblower bar is organizing to push back at what they see as an ideological attack on whistleblower lawyers.

“We have rolled up our sleeves and we are organizing,” Tom Devine of the Government Accountability Project told Corporate Crime Reporter in an interview last week. “We are not going to be passive.”

“These whistleblowers were acting within the legal rights Congress created with the whistleblower statutes,” Devine said. “In the Tamm case, the government didn’t even attempt to charge him with misconduct. His activities were legally protected. In the Bernabei case, the Department of Labor rejected the same charges when General Electric tried to censor Ms. Bernabei’s advocacy for the whistleblower in government proceedings. This is an attack by the DC Bar Counsel on the constitutional authority of Congress and the President to enact the rules of law and for judicial bodies to enforce them. The Bar Counsel is saying that its standards trump and can cancel out the free speech rules that our government has enacted to protect the public against bureaucratic misconduct.”

Former Justice Department official and whistleblower lawyer Jesselyn Radack told Corporate Crime Reporter that the Disciplinary Counsel “has a nasty history of politically-motivated bar discipline, especially against whistleblowers and attorneys for whistleblowers.”

“Like Thomas Tamm, I blew the whistle as a Justice Department attorney,” Radack said. “As with Tamm, the federal criminal case against me closed with no charges ever being brought. Afterwards, we both faced charges from the Maryland Bar, which were dismissed in a timely fashion. However, in my case, the DC Bar charges hung like a Sword of Damocles over my head for ten years. We see the exact same pattern with Tamm. The DC Bar is bringing charges 12 years after his revelation of the government’s unconstitutional and illegal warrantless wiretapping program.”

“If Tamm or I were threats to the public, the Bar would obviously want to pull our licenses as soon as possible — instead, they have taken it upon themselves to act as a retaliatory tool of the Justice Department.”

Washington University Law Professor Kathleen Clark said that “Tamm’s disclosure of the surveillance program to a Capitol Hill staffer and to the New York Times appears to be a quintessential public interest disclosure.”

“Tamm — and others within the Office of Intelligence and Policy Review (OIPR) — believed that the program was illegal,” Clark said. “Officials at the highest levels of the Justice Department had nonetheless purported to authorize it. Tamm spoke with supervisory lawyers within OIPR about it, and they apparently confirmed its illegality but weren’t doing anything about that illegality.”

“After the New York Times published articles about the program, members of Congress were up in arms about it. Eventually, Attorney General Holder acknowledged that the program was illegal.”

“It seems strange that DC’s Disciplinary Counsel would bring these charges against Thomas Tamm for his critical role in the disclosure of an illegal government surveillance program. It’s even more strange that they decided to do this more than seven years after Tamm’s role was made public.”

Whistleblower lawyer Jason Zuckerman told Corporate Crime Reporter that “as a whistleblower advocate, I am concerned about what appears to be an ideological crusade against whistleblowers and their counsel.”

“The ostensible mission of Bar Counsel is to ‘protect the public and the courts from unethical conduct by members of the D.C. Bar,’” Zuckerman said. “But despite limited resources and a backlog resulting from receiving approximately hundreds of complaints a year, the highest priority of Bar Counsel appears to be prosecuting whistleblowers and their attorneys.”

“In the Tamm matter, the conduct occurred in 2004 and in the Bernabei matter, the conduct took place in 2008. And even though the disciplinary process in DC is complaint driven, Bar Counsel chose to prosecute Bernabei without having received any complaint about her conduct in that matter. It seems very suspicious that Bar Counsel is devoting such significant resources to prosecuting Bernabei and Tamm, especially where the alleged conduct appears to fall into a gray area, if there was any violation at all, which makes it very difficult for Bar Counsel to prove by clear and convincing evidence that Bernabei and Tamm knowingly violated the Rules of Professional Conduct.”

“There seems to be a double standard. Has Bar Counsel ever prosecuted any attorneys at corporate firms that help their clients perpetrate fraud? And did Bar Counsel investigate prominent lawyer executives at Fannie Mae who appear to have engaged in actions that led to a multi-billion dollar restatement and left taxpayers footing the bill? Did Bar Counsel prosecute the attorneys that enabled large banks to nearly tank the economy? And has Bar Counsel prosecuted government attorneys that enabled torture and other flagrant unlawful human rights violations? Does Bar Counsel protect the public or does it protect the interests of big corporations and big government?”

“About one week ago, 60 Minutes aired a show in which they caught lawyers, including a former American Bar Association president, providing advice on how to move suspect money into the United States,” Zuckerman said. “Is it Bar Counsel’s position that lawyers that take steps to combat or oppose fraud should be disbarred and that lawyers that enable corporate fraud are the pinnacle of the profession? I resent that my mandatory bar dues are used to fund an office that is zealously prosecuting corporate and government whistleblowers while apparently ignoring a serious problem in the legal profession of attorneys perpetrating and enabling massive frauds.”

“What is especially odd in the Bernabei matter is that Bar Counsel is taking positions that are contrary to federal law and Supreme Court precedent. Several federal courts and indeed the Supreme Court in Lawson v. FMR have held that attorneys can bring Sarbanes-Oxley claims when they suffer retaliation for blowing the whistle. Yet in the Bernabei matter, Bar Counsel appears to claim that federal law does not preempt inconsistent state rules of professional conduct. Advancing this bizarre legal argument is an odd use of Bar Counsel’s limited resources.”

At the center of the storm is Assistant Disciplinary Counsel Hamilton P. Fox III, who is bringing the charges against Bernabei and Tamm.

Fox is a former partner at Sutherland Asbill. He currently teaches a course at Georgetown Law Center titled “Counseling the Corporation in Crisis.”

While at Sutherland Asbill, Fox represented the Israeli spy Jonathan Pollard. And a couple of years ago, he settled a high-profile run in he had with DC police over a parking dispute. Fox says DC wrote him a check for $80,000 to settle the dispute.

Fox told Corporate Crime Reporter that there is no ideological crusade against whistleblowers.
Fox said that out of the thousands of cases investigated over the past ten years by his office, he knows of only two brought against whistleblower lawyers — the Bernabei cases and the Tamm case.
Fox says that there have been many more brought against corporate lawyers.

“I can think of at least three lawyers in major law firms whom we have disciplined in recent years,” Fox said.

“And it’s simplistic to say that we are trying to trump federal law,” Fox said. “Federal law does not give lawyers the right to violate attorney-client privilege. If you hired a lawyer and disclosed to him something very bad that you have done, do you want that lawyer to be free to disclose to the public?”
Fox said that his office gets about 500 to 600 complaints about lawyers every year.

“If you go back ten years, that’s about what — 5,000 complaints?” Fox said. “And so far, we have brought two cases against whistleblower lawyers?”

“How is that a crusade?” he asked.

Fox says that if a lawyer hears from a client about activity that poses immediate risk to human health, then they would have a duty to report that to law enforcement and go public with it.

“But that’s different from the kinds of corporate wrongdoing — like misleading advertising — it depends on what the misconduct is,” Fox said.

“If the lawyer hears — I’m going to shoot my wife, you can disclose,” Fox said. “If the lawyer hears — I’m going to divorce my wife, you can’t.”

What about rampant corporate bribery?

“I actually had such a case when I was in practice,” Fox said. “I found out that agents of my client company were bribing people in a foreign country to get licenses. If I have actual knowledge of that, under rules of professional conduct, I’m required to report that up the chain within the company, to the board and to give them the opportunity to correct. If they do not correct it, then I am allowed to report it outside the company, only if to prevent the client from committing the crime or fraud and if it is reasonably certain that substantial financial injury will occur to someone else. If it is simply that some government official in some foreign country is being enriched, I cannot report it.”

“That’s the premise of our profession,” Fox said. “We withhold the secrets of our clients.”

Sarbanes-Oxley imposed a different standard, Fox admits — “probably under SOX I report to the SEC — but overall — this area of law has not yet been settled.”

Disciplinary enforcers like Fox don’t have prosecutorial discretion and thus can’t launch vendettas, he says. Every case he brings has to be approved by a superior. But he admits that in most cases, his recommendations are approved.

Devine counters that the DC Disciplinary Counsel has “gone rogue”

“The DC Bar Counsel has gone rogue in a back door attack on the rule of law as established by our Constitution,” Devine said. “It is also ignoring federal pre-emption. Prior DC Bar Counsel opinions had respected preemption and said they could trump its internal bar rules.”

Full Article & Source:
Whistleblower Lawyers Counterattack Against DC Disciplinary Counsel

Family caregivers deserve legal standing


Every day, millions of Americans face a health care crisis at home. They’re providing around-the-clock care for an ailing parent, spouse, or other relative, often while running a family and holding down an outside job. As the baby boomer generation gets grayer, and pressure to reduce medical spending mounts, more people are joining the ranks of these de facto health care providers. They deserve legal standing.

A 2015 AARP survey of Massachusetts registered voters age 45 and older found a majority have, or were, providing care for a relative who is “ill, frail, elderly, or who has a disability.” AARP has estimated the value of these unpaid services at $11.6 billion annually in Massachusetts alone.

 While family caregivers can turn to various state and national organizations for assistance and emotional support, more comprehensive action is needed on the state and federal levels. Attention at a policymaking level would bring order to a stopgap, sometimes chaotic, system that robs caregivers of dignity all too easily. A bill under consideration in the Massachusetts Legislature would allow a patient to name a family caregiver — a designation that would help legitimize the role family members play in the health care system. Under the law, patients could not be discharged from a hospital without their caregiver being notified. The bill builds in important safeguards to prevent hospitals from discharging patients without sufficient attention to what comes next: Hospitals would be required to offer detailed instructions on how to perform such tasks as administering drugs and changing bandages. Called the Caregiver Advise, Record, Enable Act, or CARE, it mirrors bills that have been passed in 18 other states. “It’s a big step in getting consistency across the board,” said state Representative Chris Walsh, the legislation’s sponsor.

These long-overdue steps could also prevent readmissions, which are all too common for elderly patients. “Hospital discharge policies really need to come into the modern age,” said John Schall, chief executive of the nonprofit Caregiver Action Network, based in Washington, D.C. “So many medical errors occur at that point.”

Another Massachusetts caregiver-related bill would build in essential workplace protections by prohibiting employers from discriminating against workers who are caring for a relative. And another proposal breaks new ground by recognizing the burden on spouses by offering a modest weekly stipend for those caring for patients covered by MassHealth — the state insurance plan for low-income and disabled residents. Other family members — including children and grandchildren — as well as friends, already are eligible for caregiver payments, but spouses are unfairly excluded.

The spouse of a patient being treated at home often “has to make some real tough choices like, ‘Do I cut back on work?’ ” noted Mike Festa, director of AARP Massachusetts, which is one of many state groups supporting the legislation.

In Washington, several efforts are underway to ease the financial burden on family caregivers. New York congresswoman Nita Lowey, for instance, is pushing a bill that would offer a Social Security credit to anyone who has to quit a job or work fewer hours to take care of a family member. In introducing the legislation, Lowey cited an astounding figure showing that the country’s 65 million unpaid caregivers lose an average of $324,000 in pay and benefits over a lifetime. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton has made family caregiving a part of her campaign platform — she also backs a Social Security credit for family caregivers, as well as a tax credit of up to $6,000 to offset expenses.

Together, these changes would make a significant difference in the lives of caregivers, and the family members who depend on them. Sooner or later, as a caregiver or patient, it’s an issue most of us will take personally.

Full Article & Source:
Family caregivers deserve legal standing

Saturday, March 12, 2016

Minnesota Conservator Leaves Trail of Complaints

A Long Lake man appointed by Minnesota courts to oversee the lives and estates of vulnerable adults is resigning from nearly five dozen cases in the wake of complaints about mismanagement and a violent attack on him by one of his clients.

Clarence Coffindaffer has been appointed in 91 vulnerable adult cases, 57 of which remain open, despite a series of criticisms from court auditors and objections to his supervision from some wards and their family members. One of his attorneys, Charles Singer, confirmed that Coffindaffer plans to quit the business as soon as possible.

“This process will take several months as there are several attorneys involved and it is not an easy task to find professionals who will take some of these cases,” Singer said.

Coffindaffer’s pending resignations likely mean added expenses for his clients and a Sisyphean task for the court as it struggles to find acceptable replacements to supervise its wards. The disruption hits Twin Cities probate courts still grappling with the 2014 collapse of another professional guardian and conservator firm known as Alternate Decision Makers Inc. (ADMI), whose founder admitted to pilfering the wards’ accounts.

Coffindaffer inherited a number of ADMI’s former clients, taking control of their finances despite his own background of financial difficulties. His 2005 personal bankruptcy petition in West Virginia was not publicly disclosed in some court records, despite a state law requiring it.

Hennepin District Judge Jamie L. Anderson wrote Coffindaffer in September demanding an explanation for late annual account filings, missing and incomplete support documentation and missing Social Security payments caused by his management failures. In January, she fined Coffindaffer $100 for failing to file required documents in one case and for failing to appear at a December court hearing. This month, she ordered him to appear before her on March 28 for failing to submit several required filings and skipping a February hearing in another case.

Auditors have raised concerns about Coffindaffer routing expense “reimbursements” for his clients through a company he founded called Valtara LLC. The company’s registration lapsed in 2009 and he only renewed it this month, after a reporter’s inquiry.

Some wards and their loved ones say they can’t be rid of Coffindaffer soon enough.

Coffindaffer became a professional guardian and conservator in 2007, two years after filing for bankruptcy. His new profession followed a career as a librarian, college administrator and professor of information technology.

Prospective conservators and guardians have been required to disclose prior bankruptcy filings since August 2013. Court filings since then state that Coffindaffer never filed for bankruptcy, or they remain silent on the issue, or they state that he filed for bankruptcy “more than 20 years earlier” and that the case number was “unknown.”

The Star Tribune obtained his bankruptcy filings online. His debts at the time included $82,000 in unsecured claims to banks and credit card companies. Coffindaffer said in the filing that he was receiving $3,660 a month in disability payments. Singer said the nature of the disability is confidential information.

Full Article and Source:
Minnesota Conservator Leaves Trail of Complaints

Guilty verdicts handed down on 11 of 17 charges in $52 million federal fraud case


After three days of deliberations, a federal jury on Monday decided that former Alaska prosecutor Mark Avery cheated his way into a wealthy, elderly widow’s trust fund in 2005, then spent wildly on vintage planes and expensive boats. The jury handed down verdicts of guilty on 11 of 17 felony counts in U.S. District Court.

But jurors found him not guilty of one count, and hung on five others.

Jurors began deliberating the $52 million fraud case Thursday morning and announced their decision Monday afternoon in a federal courtroom in Anchorage.

Avery, 56, was tried on five counts of wire fraud, 10 counts of money laundering and single counts of bank fraud and making a false statement to a bank.

Under their decision, jurors found that the fraud of the May Smith Trust added up to $31 million.

They found him not guilty on the fourth of five requests for wire transfers, which amounted to $6 million. They couldn’t decide whether Avery deceived his two fellow trustees from the very start, when he emailed a financial manager for the first $15 million drawn on a loan backed by the trust.

They also hung up on whether the initial spending amounted to money laundering, including Avery’s purchase of two RVs and his payoffs of a second mortgage, loans for three SUVs and other debt. They also couldn’t decide on another money laundering charge related to Avery making a $304,000 interest payment from, as prosecutors said, the trust-backed loan.

U.S. District Judge Ralph Beistline, who presided over a trial spanning 15 days from the start of jury selection, earlier said he was considering entering his own order of not guilty on two counts related to a separate $500,000 Wells Fargo line of credit. While jurors convicted Avery of those two charges, the judge could still rule in the defendant's favor on them.

Avery declined to comment after the verdicts were read and didn’t react in the courtroom. His attorney, Mike Dieni, also declined to comment.

Over 11 days of testimony, jurors were shown some 200 exhibits. They heard from 20 government witnesses and five from the defense, including Avery himself, who testified over one full day and parts of two others, more than any other witness.

“These guilty verdicts are clear indicators that they totally discounted his explanation and his story,” said assistant U.S. Attorney Steve Skrocki, the lead prosecutor on the case.

It’s too soon for the prosecution to say whether it intends to retry Avery on the five counts on which jurors couldn’t reach a decision.

But, Skrocki said: “This is a $30 million conviction, so it’s probably unlikely we will retry him on those charges.”

Avery was one of three trustees for the $100 million May Smith Trust, set up to provide for the care of May Wong Smith, as well as the $350 million charitable trust in the name of May and her late husband, Stanley Smith, who made a fortune in mining after World War II.  (Continue Reading)

Full Article & Source:
Guilty verdicts handed down on 11 of 17 charges in $52 million federal fraud case

Emeritus at Santa Rosa nursing home to pay $1 million in settlement


Eleanor Buckingham
A high-end Santa Rosa nursing home has agreed to pay $1 million to settle a wrongful death and elder abuse lawsuit alleging it allowed a patient to die from complications of a bedsore, attorneys said Tuesday.

Emeritus at Santa Rosa, since renamed Brookdale Fountaingrove, agreed to the payout in the 2013 death of Eleanor Buckingham, 87.

Her family alleged nursing staff erred in treating a pressure ulcer that developed on her back, withholding proper care until it became infected.

She died of sepsis after being taken to Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital, said attorneys Jeremy Fietz and Sandy Horowitz.

They said the case shows even the most expensive nursing facilities make mistakes. Emeritus charged patients about $100,000 a year to stay in the Fountaingrove Parkway facility, the attorneys said.
“I think it’s really important that people watch very carefully, no matter what nursing home their loved one gets into,” Fietz said.

Sue Becker, nursing home administrator and executive director, did not return a call Tuesday seeking comment. She was named in the suit, filed in Sonoma County Superior Court, along with Jennifer Abramson, the former director of nursing. A spokeswoman for the Tennessee-based company, Shawna Zody, did not comment.

Brookdale bought Emeritus Corporation in 2014 for a reported $1.4 billion in stock. The company owns at least three other facilities in Sonoma County.

The company released a statement Tuesday saying it has made unspecified changes since the merger, and highlighting that the lawsuit concerned events that predated the merger.

“While there were defenses to the allegations, we ultimately decided to resolve this case to put our focus on what matters most, the health and well-being of our residents,” said the statement from spokeswoman Shawna Zody.

A Bay Area watchdog said the $1 million settlement is significant since damages for simple negligence are capped at $250,000 under state law.

“A million dollars is a statement,” said Patricia McGinnis, executive director of California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform. “It says, we did something wrong.”

She said her group receives frequent complaints about corporate-owned nursing homes, including those operated by Seattle-based Emeritus and Brookdale.

“They are large, for-profit chains trying to provide healthcare,” she said. “I’m not sure they are capable of doing it.”

Buckingham, a San Francisco native who served as a civilian airplane spotter during World War II, moved to Santa Rosa with her late husband, Warren, in the 1950s. She raised two children and eventually became a pilot herself, joining the Ninety-Nines, an international organization for female fliers.

After suffering a bout of cellulitis about four years ago, she was admitted to Emeritus in November 2012 for rehabilitation with plans to return to live with her daughter in Windsor, her attorneys said.

Emeritus staff noticed the bed sore on her back at admission but did not take immediate action to treat it, the lawyers said. Instead, they allowed the wound to double in size and held her at the facility until Jan. 15 — the last day covered by Medicare, Fietz and Horowitz said.

At that point, Emeritus downgraded her treatment from skilled nursing to assisted living, the lawyers said.  (Continue Reading)

Full Article & Source:
Emeritus at Santa Rosa nursing home to pay $1 million in settlement

Woodbury Man Sentenced for Stealing Funds Intended for Oxford and Charities


Peter M. Clark, 58, of Woodbury, was sentenced to 45 months of imprisonment, followed by three years of supervised release, for stealing more than $1.8 million from the estate of an Oxford woman who died in 2010, federal authorities announced in a prepared statement Wednesday evening.

According to court documents and statements made in court, Miriam S. Strong of Oxford died on July 2, 2010. At the time of her death, Strong had a will, which left money, property and other items to a list of individuals, the Town of Oxford, the State of Connecticut and several religious and other charitable entities.

The will also called for the creation of a scholarship fund for college-bound students from Oxford.

Clark drafted the will as Strong’s attorney and served as a witness to Strong’s execution of the will.

The will named Clark and another individual as co-executors. The investigation revealed that, during the course of the administration of the will, Clark took more than $1.8 million from Strong’s estate for his own use, federal officials said.

Clark will be ordered to make restitution to the Connecticut Client Security Fund, which has reimbursed Miriam Strong’s estate.

Clark was arrested on a federal criminal complaint on May 21, 2015. On October 19, 2015, he pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud.

Clark, who is released on a $500,000 bond, was ordered to report to prison on Feb. 24.

Full Article & Source:
Woodbury Man Sentenced for Stealing Funds Intended for Oxford and Charities

Friday, March 11, 2016

Scott signs elder guardianship bill; but for some, it's too late


Lori Smith and her mother, Bunny Garst
By Barbara Peters Smith

With Gov. Rick Scott's signing of a landmark guardianship reform bill on Thursday, adult wards of the state and their families will for the first time have a number they can call for official intervention, without having to go through an attorney, when problems arise.

The bill, authored by Sen. Nancy Detert of Venice, is intended for Floridians trying to challenge the complex legal system that strips citizens of their rights after they are deemed incapable of making their own decisions. It establishes a new Office of Public and Professional Guardians, which will monitor the people paid to handle those wards' affairs, and review allegations that this sweeping trust is being violated.

Detert has said the law “will be the model for the other states,” and was inspired by the anguish of family members who have told their stories in Tallahassee to press for systemwide reform. She called the bill her “absolute top priority” for this year's session, her last as she leaves the Legislature to run for the Sarasota County Commission.

“I would be frankly devastated to leave the Senate without having finished that job,” she said after Scott signed the bill.

Detert had tried to get the measure through the Legislature last year, but it failed, in part because of Scott's concerns. This year, the governor was on board.

“We couldn't have done it without him, because we tried doing it without him and it didn't work,” Detert said. “The governor himself heard from lots of people in his travels, because Naples is one of the target areas for unscrupulous folks preying upon elderly wealthy old ladies. He heard it first hand. He was very supportive. I never doubted that he'd sign it. I'm thrilled that he did. He said he would come to our community and do a ceremonial signing, which will be great.”

For many of the families profiled in the Herald-Tribune's ongoing coverage of this topic, the new standards and scrutiny amount to a welcome change that will come too late for them personally. This month Bunny Garst of Bradenton saw her husband lose his last remaining right — to choose where he lives — after his family's costly legal struggle of more than three years with his professional guardian.

She wonders whether his case might have unfolded differently, if she could have had early access to what Detert has called a “complaint department.”

“We have to have somewhere to turn,” said Garst, who retained a series of attorneys in an effort to reverse her husband's assignment to a paid guardian — and fight that guardian's actions to sell off her husband's property. “The frustration is that all this is going on and you're totally helpless.”

In September 2011, Garst called Florida's Adult Protective Services and asked for an investigation of her husband's living situation. She was concerned, she said, that Claflin Garst Jr., a former Manatee County judge, had rapidly advancing dementia and was being unduly influenced by an employee. When she and the employee both petitioned to be named guardian, the judge appointed a professional instead.

The only right Claflin Garst retained in these proceedings was the freedom to choose his residence, and for years he remained at home with paid caregivers on his buffalo ranch — where friends and family contend that it was difficult to visit him. In February his guardian asked the court to remove that right and allow placement in a facility that offers memory care.

“Due to the deteriorating condition of the ward,” the petition states, “the aides are not able to provide the level of service required to maintain him in a safe nurturing environment.”

“That ranch means everything in the world to him,” said Bunny Garst, who was visibly upset after this petition was granted on March 1.

The guardian did not respond to a request for comment, and Claflin Garst's court-appointed attorney declined to comment.

Along with his order, 12th Judicial Circuit Chief Judge Charles E. Williams called for a status conference in 90 days to assess the ward's condition, and “strongly encouraged” his guardian and family to consider using a new, voluntary Eldercare Coordinating program to resolve their ongoing differences. But Bunny Garst said her attorney advised her that such a step at this stage would be “too little, too late.”

The number of professional guardians in Florida has grown from 23 in 2003 to nearly 500 today, and is expected to climb as the baby boom generation ages.

In a December 2014 series, “The Kindness of Strangers,” and followup stories, the Herald-Tribune chronicled the struggles of wards and their families with an underfunded legal system that draws on the life savings of wealthier wards to support the “pro bono” work of attorneys and guardians for indigent wards. The project also found that wards' rights under the statute were routinely disregarded, and that the practice of placing elders under “temporary emergency guardianship” typically led to permanent guardianship before anyone could contest the process.

Sam Sugar, an Aventura physician who founded an organization called Americans Against Abusive Probate Guardianship, said recent reforms to the system have been limited in scope, and more profound change is needed.

He worried that Detert's bill, while establishing state oversight, still leaves the burden of proof on wards and their families. And it does not allow for criminal prosecution of wrongdoing by guardians.

“The bill does nothing, absolutely nothing, to address grievances for active guardianships,” he added, “or those that have been closed by virtue of the death of the ward. The guardianship racket is so complicated and well-entrenched ... it may take something far stronger than this type of bill to adequately address it.”

WHAT THE NEW LAW WILL DO

• Encourage courts to consider appointing guardian advocates as an alternative to full guardianship.

• Place the Florida Secretary of Elder Affairs in charge of a new Office of Public and Professional Guardians.

• Fund the office with six full-time staff positions in the first year, and a recurring budget of almost $700,000.

• Direct that office to establish standards for guardians by Oct. 1.

• Generate procedures for monitoring guardians and looking into allegations against them.

• Create a way to discipline guardians who fail to meet professional standards.

• Establish a training program for guardians.

• Spell out grounds for discipline or penalties.

• Establish a matching grant program to fund local public guardianships for indigent wards.

For more information on adult guardianship in Florida, go to heraldtribune.com/guardianship

Full Article & Source:
Scott signs elder guardianship bill; but for some, it's too late

Time Share Company Accused of Elder Abuse


VENTURA, Calif. (CN) - An 81-year-old man claims in court that Diamond Resorts International, a timeshare club, defrauded him of $50,000 and keeps trying to get more.

 Louis Wolff claims Diamond Resorts International Club and six affiliates used high-pressure sales tactics to open credit cards in his name, run up bills on them "before plaintiff even realized the cards existed," and charge him more than $50,000 for "membership 'services' in DRI entities."

 Wolff sued Diamond Resorts on March 8 in Superior Court. He claims the abusive sales pitches, on the phone and in person, could last for four to five hours. And despite the $50,000 Diamond Resorts already took from him, he says, it continued to harass him for upgrades to his membership.

 "He's just a senior, with sort of the normal cognitive challenges that comes from being a senior," Wolff's attorney Eric Ridley told Courthouse News.

 "You get to an age where you become more susceptible, more trusting and maybe a little less discerning. It's not uncommon thing."

 Ridley said his client is typical of many people his age, and susceptible to high-pressure sales, which can be overwhelming.

 Diamond International sends buses to seniors' communities to take them to Nevada, Ridley said. And once they get a name, there will be a nonstop barrage of phone calls. That's what happened to him, Wolff says in the lawsuit.

 Diamond International says on its website that it has a different approach to selling its timeshares. It sells points, which can be used to stay in one a company resorts. Some members complain that the points seem to go down in value or disappear if they are not used quickly enough, or can't be redeemed for anything of value.

 New York Times economics specialist Gretchen Morgenson devoted a long Jan. 22 article to Diamond Resorts, under the headline: "The Timeshare Hard Sell Comes Roaring Back."

 One Diamond timeshare owner told Morgenson: "Diamond is much more ambitious, aggressive and downright nasty in their sales presentations compared to Marriott and Westin. Diamond just has an amazing reputation of being tough on people."

 A 77-year-old California woman told Morgenson that after a 5-hour hard sell, which left her "shaking," but which she withstood, Diamond gave her a voided receipt for a $4,840 charge on her credit card: "The representatives had been so certain that she would agree to the offer that they had charged her card for the down payment - even though she had not given approval," the Times reported.

 Diamond CEO David Palmer told Morgenson he had "belligerently zero tolerance" for any of his sales representatives who "goes off script."

 Diamond reported $845 million in revenue last year, according to the Times article, which cites two other lawsuits similar to Wolff's, one in Florida and one in California.

 "I'm glad we have these consumer protection laws in California that protect seniors," Ridley said.

 Wolff seeks restitution, rescission of contract, and punitive damages for elder abuse, unfair business practices and fraud.

 Diamond International Resorts could not be reached for comment after business hours Wednesday.

Full Article & Source:
Time Share Company Accused of Elder Abuse