Monday, March 29, 2010

Review of Probate Court Ordered

The old lady can speak barely above a whisper but it seems her voice has been heard at the Arizona Supreme Court.

Chief Justice Rebecca White Berch, in her State of the Judiciary speech last week, announced a plan to review how the state's Probate Court is operating and whether vulnerable people are being adequately protected.

In an interview this week, Berch told me the idea has been percolating for a year but that the stories of 88-year-old Marie Long and others have raised additional questions.

"I live in the real world," she said. "I've read your columns. They cause concern, and I just think that any system, it's a good idea to take a look at all of your processes and make sure things are working the way they're supposed to work."

Arizona was one of the first states to begin licensing fiduciaries in 1994 after a scandal involving an attorney and fiduciary who looted the estates of 24 elderly people they were appointed by the court to protect. It's been 16 years since those regulations were adopted and David Byers, director of the Administrative Office of the Courts, says that some courts may have slipped in enforcing safeguards that were put into place.

"Exactly what you're describing was the culture then," he said.

That culture involves a cozy group of fiduciaries and attorneys who work together on case after case and depend upon each other for contracts, making them unlikely to challenge each other's legal bills. The result is that they who are appointed to help vulnerable people also manage to help themselves to a sizable pile of cash unless a judge stops it.

Full Article and Source:
Review of Probate Court Ordered

See Also:
Judge Rules $576K to Probate Attorneys Justified

6 comments:

Lou said...

Glad to see that Chief Justice Berch is willing to open this can of worms...
Many court appointed guardians, fiduciaries and attorneys continue today in their cozy little groups exploiting the elderly!
The culture then is the culture now!!

Betty said...

I'm glad to see Chief Justice Rebecca White Birch at least admitting to the problem.

The judge on the Marie Long case should be investigated along with the judge on the Edward Ravenscroft case --- and all the cases either judge has handled.

Wondering said...

AZ has a chance here to do the right thing and set this mess right. Review the probate court and hold those accountable for their misdeeds and for not protecting the vulnerable.

Max said...

How many people complained before the voices were heard?

I'm glad Justice Berch is answering the call, but how many rings before she picked up the phone?

StandUp said...

Let's hope someone uses strong detergent and cleans this mess up properly.

Norma said...

This is very positive news. Thank you again to Laurie Roberts for her vigilence in these reports and for NASGA for posting them on the NASGA Blog.